One group of people who woke up was the National Highway Traffic Administration (NHTSA). They questioned whether CR's testing methods accurately replicated a 38 mph side-impact crash. The NHTSA says CR's tests were closer to a 70 mph crash than a less violent 38 mph. CR immediately retracted the initial report (which you can read here) and says they will re-test all safety seats. The non-profit organization did, however, stand by their initial judgements of the Evenflow Discovery and Eddie Bauer Comfort seats and says they are not safe. CR says the Evenflo doesn't meet crash standards and the Eddie Bauer could not be installed properly.
Thanks for the tip, Vinnie!
[Sources: CNN, Consumer Reports]