• Feb 15, 2011
Mazda's Pint-sized Minivan Gets Better, Not Bigger

2012 Mazda5 - Click above for high-res image gallery

Way back in 1983, Chrysler shocked the world with the introduction of the Dodge Caravan and Plymouth Voyager. The upstart family haulers took the auto industry by storm, driving a stake through the heart of station wagon sales while setting the table for Chrysler to own the minivan segment for decades to come. But that segment has evolved in the last several years, leading to a redefinition of family transportation.

First and foremost, the minivan has gone through an HGH-fueled growth spurt, adding a host of whiz-bang features like a second sliding door and ridiculously handy storage options along the way. The other big development has been a rising tide of SUVs and crossovers, which focused consumers' attention away from minivans to the point where many automakers don't even offer one anymore. But as America's suddenly all-new or heavily refreshed batch of minivans illustrate (see: Nissan Quest, Toyota Sienna and Honda Odyssey), many automakers have responded by evolving the mundane van into the automotive equivalent of a family spa day. These new vans contain near-luxury levels of comfort and convenience, and it's not at all uncommon for them to crest $40,000 or more.

If you can afford their monthly payments, the latest minivans to hit the market will likely suit your needs just fine. But what if you want something small, efficient and, perhaps most important, inexpensive? Something more like the original Caravan? Right now, there is only one choice on the market: the 2012 Mazda5. While the rest of the auto industry zigged with larger and more opulent choices, the Zoom-Zoom automaker zagged with a minivan that's nearly the size of the original Caravan, and with a price tag starting under $20,000. We took the reins of a nicely equipped 2012 Mazda5 Touring to see if Mazda's nifty little van has the chops to take on the big boys.

Continue reading...

Photos copyright ©2011 Chris Shunk / AOL

When you compare the Mazda5 to the behemoths that rule the minivan segment, it's easy to understand why we'd classify this as a microvan. But in reality, the 5 is five inches longer (and one inch narrower) than the original Dodge Caravan. What a difference 28 years makes.

The Mazda5 has soldiered through its existence in America with very little fanfare and a workmanlike attitude. When the model was introduced in 2005 as a 2006 model, Mazda wasn't interested in providing volume forecasts and marketing dollars were scarce. And who can argue that logic? At the time, all evidence pointed to the fact that Americans weren't looking to downsize. But the Mazda5 gradually gained momentum because of its unique packaging, fun-to-drive demeanor and attainable price tag. Mazda hopes to increase that momentum, slow as it may be, with a freshly reworked 5, complete with a thoroughly redesigned exterior inspired by Mazda's recently-nixed Nagare design language.

2012 Mazda5 side view2012 Mazda5 front view2012 Mazda5 rear view

Mazda says the Mazda5 was penned "as a single bead of water with ripples intentionally left on the surface, such that the body's lines express the flow of motion." Sounds fanciful, and it looks good to our eyes, though we expect the changes to be controversial among longtime Mazda5 fans. The most recognizable execution of the Nagare theme starts with the sweeping front wheel well sheetmetal that twists and swirls beyond the minivan's sliding doors. Mazda has queued up more Nagare up front, with an expressive and elegantly stamped hood that flows nicely into Mazda's Prozac-infused happy face grille. Headlamps have been given a tweak as well, though the outgoing 5's peepers were already fairly modern-looking. Out back, Mazda has decided to move away from the D-pillar-mounted vertical taillamps in favor of the more traditional horizontal units below the rear glass.

The Mazda5's cabin has also been spruced up with some of the flowing design that now adorns the MPV's exterior, though the shock and awe is relegated to the dashboard area. Gone are the cold and lifeless straight lines of the outgoing model in favor of a curvier cockpit that wraps around the driver. The last Mazda5 featured an information center at the top of the center stack. The glorified trip computer remains for 2012, but Mazda designers have managed to incorporate the unit into the dash with a twin-cowl look à la the Honda Civic. The change better integrates the display with the center stack, but we'd add that the information center now appears to be even farther away from the driver. That makes reading the text more challenging, particularly as it's rendered in red. The steering wheel has also been given a cosmetic makeover, though the easy-to-navigate redundant buttons remain unchanged.

2012 Mazda5 interior2012 Mazda5 front seats2012 Mazda5 gauges2012 Mazda5 digital readout

But while the redesign of the 5's dash looks like a step in the right direction, hard plastics remain. Sure, we would have loved soft-touch materials, but with a starting price under $20,000, we weren't expecting plush expanses.

Mazda's 2+2+2 arrangement is a largely carryover affair. This is a clear example of the 'If it ain't broke' mantra. We managed to fit four adults and two growing children in the cabin without much fuss, though sufficient leg room for adults can be a challenge, especially in the second row. The leather seats in the front row of our $24,670 Grand Touring tester were comfortable and reasonably well-bolstered, though we would have preferred heated seats with more options than 'off' and 'burn your bum in 30 seconds or less.' And if you're looking to purchase a 2012 Mazda5 and want a navigation system, you're going to have to go aftermarket. In an odd move, Mazda has scratched satellite navigation off the options list for 2012, presumably because of a low take-rate.

2012 Mazda5 rear seats2012 Mazda5 rear cargo area

Filling the 5 with people does severely limit storage space, a problem Mazda has attempted to remedy with a shallow and mostly ineffective storage beneath the second row seats. We can't help but scratch our heads and wonder why Mazda has spent its engineering dollars on creating a storage space that can only stow a couple of action figures and a travel pack of trail mix. Fortunately, if you stow the third row seats, you're rewarded with 44.4 cubic feet of cargo-swallowing space. Further, with both second- and third-row seats flattened, there's enough storage capacity to haul as much cargo as the Mazda 5's independent rear multi-link suspension can handle. Our tester didn't have any power sliding doors or auto liftgates, but that was just fine with us. Mazda decided to instead focus on openings that are light and effortless to operate – a smart cost and weight-saving move.

Check out the Short Cut tour of the Mazda 5's interior for a closer look.

The Mazda5's function-over-form approach to interior design makes sense given the minivan's thrifty price tag, but the real challenge comes when engineering "Zoom-Zoom" into a taller driving experience. Mazda has started with a new engine, replacing the 2.3-liter four-cylinder with a larger 2.5-liter mill. The new 2.5 manages 157 horsepower at 6,000 RPM and 163 pound-feet of torque at 4,000 RPM. That's only four more horsepower than the outgoing 2.3-liter engine, but torque increases by a more significant 15 lb-ft, and the engine is cleaner to boot. And you can get the Mazda5 with a new-for-2012 six-speed manual transmission, though our tester came equipped with a ho-hum five-speed slushbox. Drat.

The Mazda5's additional output wasn't included to mask additional weight. Commendably, the Mazda5 has actually shed 22 pounds for 2012, with its base weight now measuring a reasonable 3,457 pounds. That's lighter than many mid-size sedans, and lowered weight and added torque is felt when starting from a stop. The 2012 Mazda5 feels a bit peppier than its predecessor, with a (still modest) 0-60 time of about nine seconds.

2012 Mazda5 engine

We like off-the-line grunt, but the newly upsized motor doesn't give much love at highway speeds. Once in overdrive, the 5 has trouble getting out of its own way, and we're thinking most buyers will rarely engage the manual shift option to head into fourth gear while passing, no matter how well it functions. On the efficiency front, the EPA rates the Mazda5 at 21 miles per gallon around town and 28 mpg on the highway. If you're thinking 28 mpg is exactly what the Honda Odyssey can manage with a much more powerful V6, you're exactly right. But to hit 28 mpg, you'd have to step up to the six-speed auto-equipped Touring model, which STARTS at $40,755. That's roughly the cost of two base Mazda5 models plus around six months worth of gas. And since we're talking dino juice, we managed 24.3 mpg during a week of mixed driving, a number that would be tough to match with the macrovans on the market.

More power is nice, but we are, after all, talking about a Mazda. That means Zoom-Zoom engineering should grace all aspects of the ride and handling, even in a tightly packaged minivan. While we aren't willing to tag the Mazda5 as an MX-5 Miata with seating for six, we can say that it's entertaining to toss around. Mazda could have saved money with a low-tech suspension setup, but instead the automaker has sprung (*rimshot*) for an independent rear multi-link setup with a stabilizer bar and coil springs. The suspension has increased spring rates for 2012 and does a great job of keeping its composure, even when pushing the tall wagon hard on bendy roads. And it helps that the electronic steering is tight and on-center. Braking is improved as well, aided by transmission tech that downshifts to allow some engine braking.

2012 Mazda5 rear 3/4 view

It's hard not to like the Mazda5. But the big question is whether the upcoming Ford C-Max, which boasts an impressive interior and clever 5+2 seating, will limit the Mazda5's appeal. That's possible, but then again, adding more entries into the mini-minivan space may actually attract more attention to the segment. And besides, with a redesign for 2012, the Mazda5 is flat-out better inside and out than it's ever been. Add a more powerful engine, improved driving dynamics and a price that's hard to ignore, and the Mazda5 is not only the reigning king of this minor segment, but the best family hauler for under 20-large.

Photos copyright ©2011 Chris Shunk / AOL

I'm reporting this comment as:

Reported comments and users are reviewed by Autoblog staff 24 hours a day, seven days a week to determine whether they violate Community Guideline. Accounts are penalized for Community Guidelines violations and serious or repeated violations can lead to account termination.

    • 1 Second Ago
      • 3 Years Ago
      Put a Sky-D diesel engine in it and call it a day =)
      • 3 Years Ago
      I'm not sure today's "minivans" can qualify a mini. Have you seen the Nissan Quest? Holy sh t that thing is massive! Its proportions are only marginally smaller than a Ford Econoline. Mazda's 5 and Ford's upcoming C-Max are really the only true "mini"vans in the states.

      I'm hoping that Mazda will release a MazdaSpeed5! They already offer a 5 in manual and the platform is shared with the Mazda3. C'mon Mazda!
        • 3 Years Ago
        @ Alex

        That's what I keep saying. Their is nothing mini about them.

        The Sienna, Odyssey and Quest need to be referred to as vans.
        • 3 Years Ago
        Car & Driver had the very same idea! Check this out: http://www.caranddriver.com/features/09q2/return_of_the_boss_wagon_mazdaspeed_5-project_car - as a former 2005 Mazda3 and current 2010 Mazda3 owner, I love the idea. Given the smaller niche market that most Mazda products satisfy, I think there's enough business case in here to justify it. Given that the entire Mazdaspeed line has been relegated to aftermarket parts and a single factory model, though, I doubt we'll see it.
      • 3 Years Ago
      I prefer the styling of the old one, but it's still a nice little van...especially with a 6-speed manual!
      • 3 Years Ago
      I have had my Mazda5 for 3 years and despite the firm ride and hard plastics, it's been a perfect family wagon. Big cargo hatch, I can take 6 if I need to (read 4 of us and grandparents) and I can haul stuff from the big box stores very easily.
      Wish a 6-speed manual had been offered when I got mine, highway revs are too high in the 5spd.
      And direct injection would be nice too.
      • 3 Years Ago
      "Mazda's Pint-sized Minivan Gets Better, Not Bigger" AutoBlog

      "A Minivan That Keeps Getting Better Instead of Bigger" Insideline

      Hard time thinking of a better line?
      • 3 Years Ago
      too much sheet metal above the rear lights, they should be tighter with the window. The side-skirts are making that butt look a lot higher than it actually is. The rest of the design works nicely though.
      • 3 Years Ago
      I have a 2007 Nissan Quest that I love. However, we have been contemplating on trading in for something with better gas mileage. I have a 4 and 6 year old. Wondering if the Mazda5 would be a good fit for us. I am a bit spoiled with my spacious Quest.
      • 3 Years Ago
      My bestfriend owns a current 5, and to sum it up, the Ford CMax addresses all the issues that the original Mazda5 needed work on. NVH, power, another gear, better materials, more tech. I do agree though, this new styling will alienate many current Mazda5 owners, I haven't met one yet that likes the sides or the rear. Its as if they addressed an issue (the styling) that didn't need work. Should have spent the money on a few more stronger horses.
      • 2 Years Ago
      we have had this car for 2 monthes and about 3000 miles and like it a lot. First it is fun to drive and our smiles are as big as the smile on the front of the car.
      • 3 Years Ago
      My parents own the current (last?) gen Mazda5. They actually made a point to purchase that one because they didn't like the new exterior styling or the non-glossiness of the new interior. They would have been fine with those if there was a noticeable improvement overall in terms of power or interior space. The only thing my Dad says he wishes he had was the 6 speed instead of the 5.

      Point I'm trying to make is that this feels way more like a refresh than an all new model. I was hoping for a bit more improvement, and bit less side sculpting.
      • 3 Years Ago
      I still think Mazda screwed up by killing off the old MPV. My 2003 only weighs about 300 lbs more than the 5, with the right hitch and the winter/rear air package, I can tow up to 3500 lbs. It has the great 200hp/200lb/ft 3 liter Ford Duratec engine and, now that programming issues are long in the past, an outstanding 5 speed auto (what, nothing better in the intervening 8 years, Mazda?). I've carried 6 full sized adults without the suspension bottoming out. I run the heck out of it, hard acceleration and all, and in a daily commute on mixed roads it exceeds 18mpg, on highway only trips it gets close to 24. Pushing 160,000 miles, and I can't even buy a 5 for what I paid leftover in Dec 2003. It is certainly roomier and more comfy that the 5. If they would have just brought a 6 based van with a lower load floor, in the MPV size, they would have done fine.

      Not knocking the 5-it and the Cmax(Europe's Grand Cmax) are both great cars, based on the same platform, much as the 2 and the Fiesta, or the 3 and the Focus. Too bad Ford has ended the small car development process with Mazda, that is where all the great current gen Ford small cars were born, with Mazda!

      Come on, Mazda, bring back the genuine MPV, and while you are at it, bring a true compact pickup with a usable bed-even if GM DOES give the Colorado an update, there is NO GENUINE SMALL TRUCK out there, let's fill that vacuum/niche market. Mazda does that very well.......and my MPV is tired of playing pickup truck for me!
        • 3 Years Ago
        I love my MPV, its the biggest vehicle I've ever enjoyed driving. I handles way better than any car its size should, and its keeps going and going.
      • 3 Years Ago
      I have a 07 Mazda 5 with 2 young kids. The question is not this or a Suburban, but the 5 or a crossover like a Ford Flex or Chevy Traverse, or other traditional family car. It's smaller, but efficient and easier to drive.

      The 5 works great around town - good storage for Costco runs and going to the park. The sliding doors are much better for getting the kids and stuff in and out. It drives light and quick, if a little harsh. The rear seats are handy for short runs or small kids - but much better space than crammed three across in a traditional sedan.

      We are considering something bigger as the family grows, but this will stitch from the main family car my wife drives to become my commuter. We could still fit all the kids in when we need to, but it's enjoyable enough and efficient enough to make it as my daily driver.

      It's a smart choice for a young family - one of the best. This was a brilliant move to kill the MPV - good in its time - and actually downsize the minivan, make it sporty.

      Don't worry about the slightly odd exterior. The upgraded interior is brilliant, and it’s what you look at most of the time.
    • Load More Comments
    2014 Jeep Cherokee
    MSRP: $22,995 - $30,095
    2015 Mercedes-Benz E-Class
    MSRP: $51,800 - $103,200
    2014 Chevrolet Cruze
    MSRP: $17,520 - $24,985