Review: 2009 Nissan Maxima, return of the four-door sports car?

2009 Nissan Maxima - Click above for high-res image gallery
Once upon a time, labeling anything other than a two-door, two-seater a "sports car" would have been anathema to enthusiasts. And calling a mid-size sedan by the same name would have been utterly absurd. But when Nissan originally slapped the 4DSC ("four-door sports car") label on the Maxima 20 years ago, the automotive landscape was a very different place. Today, the sports sedan has been embraced by the masses, and with a series of "four-door coupes" hitting the market, consumers looking for an entertaining ride with seating for four have a host of options to choose from.
So when Nissan trotted out the all-new 2009 Maxima in New York last year and revived the 4DSC label, the automaker's past successes weighed heavily on the redesigned sedan. Would it still deliver the power and handling of its predecessors or would it be just another poseur in a see of wannabe sports sedans? More to the point: is this really a sports car? Let's find out.
Gallery: Review: 2009 Nissan Maxima
Photos Copyright ©2009 Sam Abuelsamid / Weblogs, Inc.
Nissan has always had a sporting streak running through its DNA. What began with the Datsun 240Z and 510 has evolved into 370Z, GT-R and, yes, even the Maxima. When the latest edition of the brand's flagship sedan debuted a year ago, it introduced a new design language dubbed "liquid motion." The theme was a complete departure from the sharp creases and relatively slab sides of the previous generation model, beginning with the headlights that form a stylized "L," a cue that has since been carried over to the new Z.

Another element of the new design theme which first appeared on Nissan's 2008 Forum minivan concept is the hood profile. A pair of ridges run from the grille ends to the A-pillars with the top crease chamfered at the edge. The ridges flank a wave that runs from end to end, providing visual interest both from the outside as well as the driver's seat. All four fenders swell outward, creating prominent shoulders rife with muscularity. The roofline has a fastback profile that contributes to the sedan's sporting character, but stays elevated long enough to ensure decent rear head-room before falling away.


The Maxima's styling has a lot to like, but there are some questionable details. From where we sit, the weakest styling element is the front fascia and the grille housed within. From certain angles, the nose looks too low and too heavy, with alarming amounts of overhang – and the same issue carries over to the rear. In both cases, a contributing factor may be the revised proportions that come from the two-inch shorter wheelbase compared to the 2008 model, along with a four-inch shorter overall length.

Inside, the Maxima is a curious mix of premium and cheap. The shapes and textures have attractive colors and textures, but aside from the top of the dash, the rest of the surfaces surrounding the driver are hard plastics. While most of the pieces don't deliver luxurious tactility, the matte finishes look pleasant enough and are well finished with no rough or uneven edges. Those surfaces that the driver comes into contact with most often are finished in leather, including the thick-rimmed, heated steering wheel.

The driver's seat is another mixed bag, with eight-way power adjustability, along with a very welcome manually adjustable thigh support. Unfortunately, we had issues with getting the seat back to fit comfortably, as the upper portion felt slightly lumpy and a bit too thick. The standard rear seat features a 60/40 split seat back. However, if you opt for the $3,450 premium package fitted to our test car, the rear seating area is replaced with a set of re-contoured buckets. As such, the seat back is fixed in place with only a center pass through for long, skinny items. The premium package also includes a dual panel glass moonroof, although only the front half opens.


If the Maxima is supposed to be a sports car, it has to be packing a great engine. And as we'd expect from the automaker, it doesn't disappoint. As a modern Nissan, it's only fitting that the Maxima is powered by the 3.5-liter VQ V6 as used in the 350Z and numerous Infiniti models. Unlike the Z, however, the engine is mounted transversely, driving the front wheels through an updated version of Nissan's Xtronic continuously variable transmission. In a marked departure from most CVT transmissions, the programming on the Maxima's unit doesn't have the unnerving characteristic of holding the engine at a constant speed as obviously while accelerating. Instead, you get to listen to that fabulous six as the revs climb. Whether this unique arrangement ultimately takes a toll on overall fuel efficiency is a topic we'll leave open for discussion.


In addition to the normal "D" mode, the Maxima offers a more aggressive "Ds" as well as full "manual" option. The aforementioned premium pack includes steering wheel-mounted paddle shifters in addition to the tap shift gate on the console that allows the selection of six pre-programmed "ratios." In "Ds" mode, the transmission keeps the engine climbing towards the redline before shifting, and like most similarly equipped cars, it also downshifts while decelerating to provide engine braking.

So does the Maxima drive like a sports car? It's certainly has the right engine, with 290 hp and 261 lb-ft of twist providing brisk acceleration and the run to 60 mph consistently coming up in less than six seconds. Nissan engineers have done an admirable job of configuring the front suspension to keep the Maxima from veering off into the ditch when the go pedal is pressed to the floor, and the VQ is always good for audible delights and this installation is no exception. As the revs climb, a thrilling mechanical symphony emanates from under the hood while a sharp bark – distinctly reminiscent of the Z – comes from the exhaust under hard acceleration. In normal "Drive" mode, initial throttle tip-in feels a bit lazy, but pulling the shifter back into "Ds" seems to to remedy the issue. And although you can't get a proper manual transmission in the Maxima, if you want control of the ratios, tapping the paddles or the shift lever produces quick gear changes that put you right into the powerband.


But delivering on the sports car experience is about more than just acceleration. Eventually, the time comes to change direction. The leather-wrapped tiller provides precise control over the heading with no free-play and a measured reaction to torque in proportion to cornering forces. Compared to the Acura TL, the Maxima's steering feels much more natural and fun to toss into corners, provided that the pavement remains smooth. The spring rates provide a good balance between ride quality and road holding, but the damping needs more tweaking. When the road surface gets uneven, the rebound damping comes across as weak and the Maxima can feel floaty. It's nothing that can't be easily fixed, but it's not quite right for a sports car. When the time comes to scrub off speed, the brakes feel fully up to the task, and if things begin to go pear-shaped, the stability control engages smoothly without jerking the car around.

When playtime is over and a road-trip or gentle commute is in order, the Maxima is a pleasant place to be. Wind noise on the highway is nicely subdued and the XM NavTraffic system will help you avoid getting stuck in a jam. Our test car was the uplevel SV trim with a base price of $31,990, and with the premium and technology packages, the bottom line swelled to $38,535 (including delivery). When venturing into that price point, the Maxima's four-door sports car designation truly comes into question. Does it deliver? Not quite. It's a handsome sedan with a healthy dose of engagement. It's not so large and heavy that it feels ponderous, and having a VQ35 at your command is always a good thing. So... sports sedan? Yes. But this is no Z, and the 4DSC label may be going a bit too far. Now, if Nissan went back to a rear-drive Maxima that might be another story. But that car already exists. It's called the Infiniti G37.
Gallery: Review: 2009 Nissan Maxima
Photos Copyright ©2009 Sam Abuelsamid / Weblogs, Inc.








Get a WordPress.com Blog




Reader Comments (Page 1 of 6)
JDMlover 12:05PM (4/15/2009)
Return of the four-door sports car?
No.
Reply
James 12:16PM (4/15/2009)
A "4D (transverse engine/fwd) SC"...
Thanks, but no thanks Nissan.
lowmilelude 12:45PM (4/15/2009)
Agreed. FWD = not a sports car.
Mr.Oak 1:02PM (4/15/2009)
Not sure I agree with the title o this post.
M3 = 4 door sports car.
CTS-V = 4 door sports car.
Acura TL = 4 door sports car.
G8 = 4 door sports car.
Evo = 4 door sports car.
WRX = 4 door sports car.
Hell I'll even throw in the Cobalt SS 4 dr.
The world was not sitting around waiting on Nissan to re-invent the 4 door sports car, it's been here all along.
Johnnie 1:14PM (4/15/2009)
While I agree that those cars you list above are sportier cars that others, I don't think that they are traditional sports cars. Drive a G8 and then a 350Z or a 911 and you'll quickly see the difference.
Did you really put an Acura TL in that list of 4 door sports cars? LOL
Harley Cook 1:25PM (4/15/2009)
How about a Audi S4 Mr. Oak?
Rob 1:24PM (4/15/2009)
Agree with you guys. FWD+ Automatic = NOT a sports car. Ever.
This part was hilarious too: "Nissan has always had a sporting streak running through its DNA. What began with the Datsun 240Z and 510 has evolved into 370Z, GT-R and, yes, even the Maxima."
which basically ignores ALL the garbage that nissan produced between 1977 through 2006. Honda generally has some racing DNA in their products, but Nissans have always had some DNA of cheap japanese plastic garbage in them, IMHO.
BoxerFanatic 2:12PM (4/15/2009)
@Mr. Oak...
M3 = 4 door SPORT SEDAN
CTS-V = 4 door SPORT SEDAN
Acura TL = 4 door SEDAN. A-spec MAYBE sport.
G8 = 4 door HEAVY SPORT SEDAN
Evo = 4 door Sport Compact/Rally-rep
WRX = 4 door Sport Compact/Rally-rep.
Hell I'll even throw in the Cobalt SS 4 dr. - 4-door Sport Compact.
They are all performance cars, except maybe the TL. But none of them are sports cars. They are powerful versions of already designed mainstream sedans or economy cars. They are not purpose built for handling performance.
inteller 2:20PM (4/15/2009)
so a sedan is not a car? give me a f-in break.
The Maxima is a turd. In fact I cannot for my life remember when it wasn't a turd. Nissan is clinging to some obscrue time when maybe an early 90s maxima was in some japanese race series and suddenly it has permanent race car genes....not.
I also don't spot too many of these turds, probably because for the same money you can get into a nice G37 coupe or sedan.
iamhoff 3:15PM (4/15/2009)
Needs a proper 6 speed manual.
KeatMP 7:37PM (4/15/2009)
Finally a post of JDMlover's I can agree with.
I should enjoy this while it lasts.
My RX8 SS 10:17PM (4/16/2009)
so what is your opinion as the whether the 4 dr. RX 8 is a proper sports car, or sports sedan? or sports coupe?
zamafir 7:55PM (4/19/2009)
agreed. i don't care what it is, nothing with a cvt between the driver and the engine is a sports car. DSG is as far from a manual as anything 'sporty' should stray.
larry a 12:22AM (4/20/2009)
@RX8 SS: The RX-8 is a sports car through and through, it just doesnt have any balls. Double wishbone suspension, multilink rear suspension AND a 50/50 weight distribution, hell yeah its definitely a sports car. With the RX-8 you're not getting a torque monster you're getting a car that can handle just about anything that includes supercars. The suicide doors really helped with your guys insurance rates..
Anyway, a "sports car" is a car that has 2 doors, preferably under 3000 lbs, RWD, and is equipped with a manual transmission. The opposite of a sports car is 4 doors, heavy, automatic, and FWD which is everything that the Maxima is.
Article = FAIL
Ian 9:28AM (4/20/2009)
Really? Thats the definition of a sports car? Says who? Any car I drive for sport is considered a sports car for me. Wether thats a VW Scirocco or a Trailblazer SS, or a Ferrari F430. Sports car is in the eye of the beholder, its just a LABEL. Like Cross-over, SUV, CUV, Sedan, etc.
Matt 11:09PM (4/20/2009)
Starting at $32,000 for that trim level? Sorry, but ick. At least the Pontiac G8 gives you 360 hp and 382 ft-lbs for their their thousand dollar sedan...
Sorry, but I'd rather get a CTS, G37, MKZ, or hell, even a boring, ugly Cam.. I mean Lexus.
why not the LS2LS7? 12:05PM (4/15/2009)
The Maxima never lost its performance. It simply lost its way. Becoming ugly as sin (for 3 model revs!) was strike one, but the killing blow was you could get an Altima with the same motor for less money.
Copying the rear from the Altima coupe onto the Maxima has not fixed either of these problems.
Reply
geo.stewart 12:50PM (4/15/2009)
not only that, you get the same interior space as the altima. for a while the altima had more
Steve 12:10PM (4/15/2009)
I think it's a damn fine looking car, but I question all the power it has going to the front wheels, and not causing excessive torque steer.
If they could remedy that with a 4WD system similar to the one in the G37x, or maybe the GT-R, it would be a serious consideration for me, but for now, I feel that other then the looks, it's no different then the previous generation to me.
Reply
JDMlover 12:27PM (4/15/2009)
Get your eyes checked. Fast.
This car is all over the place...looks like a perfect ball of clay...that was then squeezed in the palm of my fist.