Buyers cross-shopping this trio are usually hauling kids, which makes rear-seat protection and crash-avoidance technology the priorities. All three earn respectable marks from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, and each comes with a broad set of standard driver aids. The deciding factors are the exact IIHS award tier and how much protective hardware is standard rather than optional. On that basis, the Subaru Ascent takes the win, with the Telluride right on its heels and the Atlas a solid third.
IIHS award tiers
The IIHS awards separate the field cleanly. The Ascent earns the 2026 Top Safety Pick+, the Institute’s top rating, which demands good scores across all three crash tests, good pedestrian front crash prevention, and acceptable or good headlights on every trim. The Telluride also reaches the Top Safety Pick+ tier, matching the Subaru’s crash-protection credentials and confirming its reputation as one of the safer family haulers on sale.
Volkswagen
The Atlas earns a Top Safety Pick, one step below the plus tier. That is still a strong result and means it protects occupants well, but under the current criteria, it does not quite match the other two. It is worth noting that the Atlas in this form is the outgoing version of the design, with a redesign on the way that could change its standing.
(C) 2025 Doug Berger | DBPics
Standard driver assistance
Where the Ascent pulls ahead is standard equipment. Every Ascent includes Subaru’s EyeSight suite with automatic emergency braking, lane-keeping, and adaptive cruise control, and just as importantly, it comes with standard symmetrical all-wheel drive. That extra traction is a genuine, real-world safety advantage in rain, snow, and loose surfaces, and it is standard rather than a pricey option.
Kia fits the Telluride with a thorough set of driver aids, including forward collision-avoidance assist and lane-keeping, with blind-spot and other features widely available, though all-wheel drive is optional rather than standard. Volkswagen equips the Atlas with its IQ.Drive assistance package, which is competitive, but again, all-wheel drive costs extra. For a family that wants the most protection working for them out of the box, the Subaru’s standard traction and driver-assist combination is the strongest.
Volkswagen
Everyday safety
Real-world safety is not only about crash tests. The Telluride offers one of the roomiest and most comfortable three-row cabins in the class, which matters for keeping occupants properly seated and belted on long trips, and it remains a superb all-around family vehicle. The Atlas counters with a genuinely usable third row and a straightforward, sturdy feel.
The Ascent’s argument is that it combines top-tier crash results with the all-weather security of standard all-wheel drive, a package none of its rivals here quite matches without stepping up the options list. For families in regions that see real winters, that standard traction can matter as much as a crash-test score.
So which one is the safest?
The Subaru Ascent is the safest of the three. It earns the 2026 IIHS Top Safety Pick+, includes the full EyeSight driver-assistance suite as standard, and adds standard all-wheel drive that improves safety in exactly the conditions where families need it most. The Kia Telluride is essentially tied on crash protection and is the better pick for a buyer who prioritizes interior space and comfort and does not need standard all-wheel drive. The Volkswagen Atlas is a dependable, safe choice and fine for many families, but as a Top Safety Pick rather than a plus, and with a redesign looming, it lands third here. Shoppers focused strictly on safety should start with the Ascent.
About the author
Kyle Edward
Editor-in-Chief, Autoblog