Filed under: Etc.
Slideshow of NYC's first automated parking garage
UPDATE: Video from Popular Mechanics added after jump
We already told you about AutoMotion's New York garage. It's that nifty robotic parking garage that promised to do a much better job than the country's first attempt at automated parking in New Jersey. That was the one that managed to drop a Cadillac Deville and a Jeep from pretty high up. It also trapped approximately 300 vehicles inside for 26 hours when the city's contract with the software company responsible for running the garage expired. That situation has been cleared up, apparently, and hopes for the new garage in NY are high as well.
The new robotic garage opened in Chinatown in early February. Built and run by AutoMotion Parking Systems, it stores 67 cars underground in the same amount of space a traditional garage could only fit 24. All for just $25/day or $400/month, which seems to be competitive for NYC parking. AutoMotion claims there's next-to no chance of any problems like those experienced in NJ. And now we have a slideshow from the New York Times portraying the whole process step-by-step. Click the read link to see the M3 convertible disappear into the bowels of the system and return to the surface unscathed.
[Source: The New York Times, Popular Mechanics]
_opt_thumbnail.jpg)
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Todd 2:56PM (3/05/2007)
The biggest problem I see with these units is that it can't handle volume. It appears from the setup that it can only handle one car at a time. Volume will be an issue anywhere property value and density is high enough to warrant such a space saving unit. How many people are already tired of waiting in the long lines to get out of some garage units? Think how bad this one would be.
Reply
Rick Lyon 3:17PM (3/05/2007)
Hmm, what does it take, like 20 minutes to get your car? Then you have to deal with random shut downs, freezes, crashes, reboots, hacks, etc? It can fit 3 times as many cars and yet charges exactly the same as traditional alternatives? They seem greedy and should have been cheaper to start. I'd still be too scared to trust my car to a 2nd gen auto parking unit.
Reply
TDIMeister 3:24PM (3/05/2007)
It would be cool if a park house copies the design of the twin-glass towers at the Volkswagen Autostadt in Wolfsburg. Both are said to have a combined capacity of 800 cars, and robots fetch and place each car like a massive (and expensive!) vending machine.
Reply
Bryan 3:45PM (3/05/2007)
Talk about lazy. What is this world coming to? I prefer to park my own vehicle, I try to stay away from valet anytime I can. What happens if you need your vehicle and the machine breaks? I hope they have other ways of getting it out!
Reply
Alex 3:53PM (3/05/2007)
Does anybody know how long the whole process takes to put a car away and come up for a new car? How much does this system cost to implement?
Reply
r.yo 4:09PM (3/05/2007)
I would be frustrated to stare at the unopened garage door and wait for my car to be retrieved, even if it took less overall time than walking to a spot and navigating through a traditional garage.
HOWEVER... if I was able to watch the machine in action... through big windows or on tv monitors... then not only would I not mind the wait, there's a good chance I would just hang out in the garage and watch the robot filing cars for hours on end.
It's like waiting for an elevator... irritating on floors 2 and higher, but slightly less irritating in the lobby, when you can watch all the floor numbers light up as the elevator moves up and down.
Or maybe I'm just easily amused.
Reply
mr.ed 4:17PM (3/05/2007)
Think about it: If it's like the European garages, You lock it and take the keys. Nobody to take it for a joyride or rummage through your stuff. How much wait is that worth?
Reply
mark 4:45PM (3/05/2007)
This is a GREAT idea! No more attendants taking a car for a joyride, or stealing change, or worse. No one having your keys either!
I, for one, wouldn't mind using this system. I too would be amused just watching the system. But for increased security, I wouldn't mind not being able to see. Imagine theives would try to get to the cars if they knew what was parked in there (see through the glass).
Reply
David 5:13PM (3/05/2007)
Doesn't that white car in the promotional pictures look like a Ford Falcon (the car below the BMW X5)?
Reply
Sean Flanagan 5:22PM (3/05/2007)
It amazes me that there are parking garage Luddites among the readership of Autoblog...
Having used traditional parking systems around Manhattan, this is by far the best option in my opinion. Your other choice (besides self-park garages, of which there are not very many) is an empty lot with individual vehicle lifts and attendants with both the willingness and ability to move your car on an hourly basis. You still have to wait for some dude to move everyone else's car out of the way to get yours out, so time is hardly a factor here.
Reply
fizzandpop 5:30PM (3/05/2007)
#10 Anyone who thinks this is a dumb idea and says things like "I always park my car myself", lives in the suburbs and has no idea about parking in cities. Ignorance is bliss I guess. I know suburbanites who can't parallel park. It's astounding how these people have developed into a motoring sub-species so quickly. And when they actually get out of the cars in the city, they all walk along side-by-side, totally unware that poeple are trying to get around them. It's a laugh watching them try to figure out how to use a cross walk.
Reply
andy 5:33PM (3/05/2007)
Nothing new, Tokyo has been doing this for years.
Reply
Bryan 5:44PM (3/05/2007)
Hey #11 I am a suburbanite born and raised..on the border of Houston. Just because someone lives in the burbs does not mean they do not know anything about parking in downtown areas. I for one rather park it myself. I don't care for valet either. The good thing about Houston though, its mixed. Were there are parking garages and valet, you can pretty much bet there are places you can park yourself as well. Doesn't mean you will find one, but the diversity of parking options we have here is a good thing, expecially with so many people moving here each here! I think a lot of technology has made us ridiculously lazy, therefore, I wouldn't even think of using this system.
Reply
Tina Silva 5:48PM (3/05/2007)
Hum...don't know how that's going to be effective since there are so many drivers in NYC...But then again, if Japan has automated parking garages and they have tons of people too, then I don't see NYC having a problem.
Tina Silva
http://redirect.alexa.com/redirect?blog.pimentels-photography.com/
Reply
Anthony 5:49PM (3/05/2007)
NOOO!!! I do valet parking over the summers, I have a great time driving all of your nice cars, please don't take that away from me! I'm begging you!
Reply
fizzandpop 7:19PM (3/05/2007)
#13: Houston isn't Manhattan, is it?
Reply
Rodion 10:53PM (3/05/2007)
I agree that technology can make us lazy. Have you seen episode of Sarah Silverman not being able to find TV remote so she ends up being forced to watch AIDS special?
But at same time, hey man this is New York. A hundred miles an hour, no time to slow down, operate on 4 coffees per day. This sort of a solution makes terrific sense for New York, and other heavily congested cities. Houston is hardly that, completely different culture, more laid back. Can't argue that point. So from marketing perspective automated parking a brilliant utilization of tried and tested technology. Props to all from NY! "Behold as I send you as sheep amidst the wolves" - Devil's Advocate.
Reply
Leo 12:28AM (3/06/2007)
I do not understand why everyone keeps saying that people are just being lazy. Efficient use of space is THE issue, real estate isn't exactly cheap in Manhattan.
#13- lemme guess... The Woodlands, Sugar Land or Katy?
Reply
Toy Yoda 2:41AM (3/06/2007)
This is good news for NYC where real estate is scarce. But, I'm wondering if parking lots charge too little, anyways. When I drive down to the West Village and the lots are packed on the weekends, and you still have to pay like over $30 bucks for the night, makes you wonder if the city is artificially lowering the price of parking.
Reply
eDamo 10:46AM (3/06/2007)
David, I too thought the white car looked like the Falcon. Interesting...
Reply