Allegedly, two years ago, biodiesel train shipments (not pictured) were sent back and forth several times between Canada and the US by CN Rail but were never unloaded. The shipping company appeared to make $2.6 million in Canadian dollars for the effort. While it seems odd that CN Rail would repeatedly transport goods but not unload them, the company claims it followed its legal obligations. "CN met its obligations as a common carrier and we have no further comment," CN spokesman Mark Hallman told CBC.
It seems that a lot was going on behind the scenes for these rail shipments that were made between June 15 and 28, 2010. According to a railway worker who spoke to CBC News anonymously due to fear of being fired, "In 25 years, I'd never done anything like it. The clerk told me it was some kind of money grab. We just did what we were told."
CBC News alleges it gained access to internal CN records that indicate fraud. Train 503 shipped biodiesel to Port Huron, MI, from Sarnia, Ont., and Train 504 brought them back. Sometimes rail cars were added and removed – between 68 and 89 cars would go at a time – and as soon as the paperwork and car shuffling were completed, the biodiesel made the return trip.
This train would usually make one trip per day to Port Huron, but maximizing the number of trips can make a lot of money for the company, said Teresa Edwards, CN's manager of transportation for Port Huron/Sarnia, in an email. Each move cleared customs to cross the border, which meant more revenue was generated for Port Huron/Sarnia. "If we can get in more flips back and forth we will attempt to do so," Edward wrote. Edwards didn't return phone calls to CBC News.
Two US biodiesel companies were listed as customers – HeroBX and Northern Biodiesel, and neither responded to calls from CBC. A Canadian company, Bioversal Trading Inc., is being investigated by the Canada Border Services Agency on allegations of false statements to avoid duties in shipping biodiesel to Romania and Italy. CN records say Bioversal arranged the train shipments investigated by CBC News.
Biodiesel producers are in a difficult situation, competing with regular diesel at fuel stations all across North America and with questionable characters hurting the industry's image. It's a tough business to be in.