KiaA couple weeks ago, J.D. Power released its latest Initial Quality Study, which gave high marks to Porsche, Hyundai and General Motors, with the latter earning more individual IQS awards than any other manufacturer. Now, it's Strategic Vision's turn, and it's doling out its praise not to Porsche, but to Tesla, which wasn't even included in the JD Power IQS.

The Model S was named the best vehicle overall in total quality, while Porsche's corporate brother and endurance-racing rival, Audi, was named the best premium brand, alongside Jaguar. Strategic Vision cited the Q5 and the ancient Q7 for individual segment awards, as well as the A5, which was a mere point off the top of its segment. SV also handed out compliments for the Audi's interior work. The win for the German brand is a nice improvement over its IQS score, with which it landed above the industry average, but solidly mid-pack.

Jaguar was without a segment winner, although SV did say that the Indian-owned English brand had a number of vehicles very near the top of their segments. This is the second significant win for Jag in two weeks, after it finished second overall on the JD Power IQS a few weeks ago.

In a surprise win, Kia took the title for mainstream manufacturers, with Strategic Vision calling out the Soul and the Optima for their "youthful, cool styling cues that not only make a strong statement but offer a solid foundation of quality." The South Korean brand took seventh in the JD Power IQS.

Notable segment winners include a few that left us scratching our heads, like the Mitsubishi Lancer tying the Dodge Dart for the best small car, and the Mini Cooper Roadster beating out the Mazda MX-5 Miata for the Standard Convertible segment. Others, though, were more predictable – the Chevrolet Corvette Stingray topped its segment, as did the Volkswagen Golf, Lexus IS and Mercedes-Benz SL.

While Strategic Vision calls this study its Total Quality Index, unlike JD Power, there's more to it than simple reliability. In addition to reliability, it also analyzes positive and negative experiences from consumers as they relate to problems with their vehicle, the driving experience and other, unnamed measures.

"Quality is much more than simply counting problems and watching for the horse race," Darrel Edwards, the founder and executive chairman of Strategic Vision, said in what seemed like a thinly veiled shot at JD Power. "When we declare Total Quality rankings, you're seeing results of something meaningful and predictive, which are the result of measuring what matters to the customer."

You can view the full press release from Strategic Vision below, which includes a complete listing of winners in each category.
Show full PR text
Tesla Best Model; Audi, Jaguar and Kia Top Brands in Total Quality: TQI Helps Predict Future Success
The 2014 Total Quality Awards

San Diego - Strategic Vision has released the results of its 19th annual Total Quality Index™ (TQI) study with thought-provoking results. "What we learn from this year's Total Quality results is the need for complete understanding of how buyers are influenced and it's not just by counting problems. TQI absolutely offers a glimpse into the future, as it did seven years ago when we headlined our TQI results, '... Perceived Quality the New Paradigm ...' where we predicted Hyundai's successes through 2013," says Alexander Edwards, President of Strategic Vision. "Back then, many people may have questioned our 2007 results, but no one can deny the success Hyundai enjoyed. With all the attention on furthering Alternative Powertrains (APT) (plug-in electrics, hybrids, etc.), the most competitive landscape in history, Tesla Model S being the Best Model in Total Quality, and Kia being one of the Best Brands, it seems very predictive to pay close attention to the Total Quality concept of measuring how customers judge quality," continues Edwards.

Audi and Jaguar shared leadership as the best Luxury brands in Total Quality and remarkably, Kia had the highest Total Quality score of non-Luxury brands. "All I can say to manufacturers is prepare to listen carefully to what car buyers are saying through these scores, be nimble and include 'True Innovation' that is bold and smart," says Christopher Chaney, Strategic Vision Senior Vice President. "Tesla built a vehicle that generated love in attributes that were most important to segment buyers. Tesla isn't an electric vehicle that just has good features, but instead it's a luxurious sports sedan that has 'True Innovation,' as well as a rocket-like speed and drive feeling, that just happens to be an electric vehicle. I would call on all manufacturers looking toward electrification to implement a mantra of building super cool transportation that impresses the heck out of customers, and 'happens to be electric.' Very few people are looking for an overpriced electric breadbox/toaster with nothing cool. Consumers are powerful, have the Internet and know how to use calculators," continues Chaney.

Audi's unique exterior styling and interior appointments helped it produce segment winners A5 Coupe, Q5 and Q7. Jaguar did not have a segment leader, but had several models ranked very high and likewise gave customers something uniquely appealing. The Kia brand has come on strong with segment winners Soul and Optima, with models strong in youthful, cool styling cues and that not only make a strong statement but offer a solid foundation of quality. As if to highlight these results, although not included in this TQI analysis, Strategic Vision's New Vehicle Experience Study (NVES) data shows the Kia K900 as taking some sales from luxury brands.

The Strategic Vision Total Quality Index score is a holistic measure that encompasses positive and negative product experiences including reliability, actual problems, driving excitement and other measures that collectively are energized by the emotional response associated with the aggregate of all those experiences – hence Total Quality. "Quality is much more than simply counting problems and watching for the horse race," says Darrel Edwards, Ph.D. Founder and Executive Chairman of Strategic Vision. "When we declare Total Quality rankings, you're seeing results of something meaningful and predictive, which are the result of measuring what matters to the customer. We use discriminating survey scales that capture the contraction of values and emotions: Love-it, Delightful, Excellent, Satisfactory, Unsatisfactory, a Failure and Hate-it," says Dr. Edwards who promoted use of the scale decades ago.

In addition to the vehicles mentioned, other manufacturers like Volkswagen continue leading with Golf and other models. Chrysler continues a strong presence in Dodge Dart, a Small Car Segment co-leader with Mitsubishi Lancer, and Dodge's Charger and Durango models in their segments. Ford continues to improve and in this study having segment winners C-MAX Energi, Flex and Expedition with Lincoln MKZ Hybrid. Strategic Vision's study of Total Quality not only reflects how owners experience quality, but also offers a look into the future of what is needed to sell. Toyota/Lexus had segment leaders Tundra, IS Sedan and GX 460 and still provides class-leading foundational attributes of quality. These elements should not be counted out according to researchers. Likewise, other domestics are staying close with GM having four leaders, despite recent challenges.

Based on Strategic Vision's quantitative "ValueCentered®" NVES study of 38,361 owners the Total Quality Index results presented contain the number one ranked vehicles in Total Quality in their segments as rated by new vehicle buyers:
Segment Winner(s) TQI Score
Micro Car Smart fortwo Coupe 855
Small Car Dodge Dart
Mitsubishi Lancer
873
873
Small Multi-Function Car Kia Soul
Volkswagen Golf
882
882
Small Alternative Powertrain (APT) Car Ford C-MAX Energi 865
Mid-Size Car Subaru Impreza Sedan
Kia Optima
922
920
Mid-Size Multi-Function Car Honda Accord Crosstour 885
Mid-Size Alternative Powertrain (APT) Car Chevrolet Volt
Hyundai Sonata Hybrid
863
863
Full-Size Car Dodge Charger 912
Near-Luxury Car Lexus IS Sedan 938
Near-Luxury Alternative Powertrain (APT) Car Lincoln MKZ Hybrid 902
Luxury Car BMW 6-Series Gran Coupe 937
Luxury Multi-Function Car Volvo XC70 897
Specialty Coupe MINI Cooper Countryman 915
Premium Coupe Chevrolet Corvette Coupe
Audi A5 Coupe
930
929
Standard Convertible MINI Cooper Roadster 931
Premium Convertible/Roadster Mercedes SL-Class 957
Standard Pickup Honda Ridgeline 845
Full-Size Pickup Ford F-150
Toyota Tundra
GMC Sierra 1500
892
891
890
Heavy Duty Pickup Ford F-250/350
Chevrolet Silverado 2500/3500
Ram 2500/3500
868
867
866
Entry SUV Jeep Wrangler Unlimited 870
Entry CUV Hyundai Tucson 887
Mid-Size SUV Dodge Durango 889
Mid-Size CUV Ford Flex 915
Full-Size Utility Ford Expedition 905
Near-Luxury Utility Audi Q5 926
Luxury SUV Lexus GX 460 933
Luxury CUV Audi Q7 942
Minivan Nissan Quest 856

Strategic Vision is a research-based consultancy with over thirty-five years of experience in understanding the consumers' and constituents' decision-making systems for a variety of Fortune 100 clients, including most automotive manufacturers. Its unique expertise is in identifying consumers' comprehensive, motivational hierarchies, including the product attributes, personal benefits, value/emotions and images that drive perceptions and behaviors. J. Susan Johnson, CEO of Strategic Vision, coined the phrase and implemented measuring scales of "True Innovators" (or "True Innovation"), meaning innovation that is rich, makes an impact, intuitive, motivational, in-depth and specific. The ValueCentered® psychology and research methods were defined by Dr. Darrel Edwards in 1968, and enhanced by co-founders J. Susan Johnson (1972) and Sharon Shedroff (1975). For further information, contact Alexander Edwards or Christopher Chaney at (858) 576-7141.


I'm reporting this comment as:

Reported comments and users are reviewed by Autoblog staff 24 hours a day, seven days a week to determine whether they violate Community Guideline. Accounts are penalized for Community Guidelines violations and serious or repeated violations can lead to account termination.


    • 1 Second Ago
  • 32 Comments
      Cruising
      • 5 Months Ago
      Interesting, some of the cars on the list barely get mentioned these days or are not talked fondly of made it on the list. Nissan Quest barely ever gets mentioned outside of the Toyota vs. Honda vs. Chrysler chatter. The Expedition does not really seem to get much attention these days. People always fuss about Honda Accord Crosstour styling. Mitsubishi Lancer, a older product somehow still is relevant and the Dart is holding it's own despite people always focusing on the Ford, Mazda etc...competitors. What's also interesting but not surprising is all three HD domestic trucks made the list. The Tundra made the list for full-size truck within a point or two of the Ford and GMC. Interesting so many "underdogs" of the segments made it on the list, sometimes it's the cars least talked about that might be worth looking at it.
      churchmotor
      • 5 Months Ago
      I'm not sure which is more idiotic, this, or the IQS. Completely worthless metric for future car buyers.
        normc32
        • 5 Months Ago
        @churchmotor
        Got Honda?
        NightFlight
        • 5 Months Ago
        @churchmotor
        If Honda won you'd be bragging to no end....
        creamwobbly
        • 5 Months Ago
        @churchmotor
        The only metric worth paying attention to is the test drive. Do it right: test it. Not just around the block. If the salesman won't let you, what are they trying to hide? But seriously, buying a new car is an exercise for people with money to throw away.
      knightrider_6
      • 5 Months Ago
      The words "Audi" and "quality" should not be used in same sentence.
        Trevor
        • 5 Months Ago
        @knightrider_6
        Funny "Recall" and "Toyota" ALWAYS seem to be used in the same sentence.
          clquake
          • 5 Months Ago
          @Trevor
          You must have missed the entire world of automotive news for the first six months of the year.
      Revis Goodworth
      • 5 Months Ago
      I guess Honduhblog can't process anything that doesn't have Honduh at the top of the list. I'm sure they are scratching their heads over these results.
        normc32
        • 5 Months Ago
        @Revis Goodworth
        Hit the nail on the head!
        • 5 Months Ago
        @Revis Goodworth
        [blocked]
      FRD
      • 5 Months Ago
      I never thought I would ever own a KIA, but I bought a 2013 Sportage in 2012. I am completely satisfied with it and would say it is definitely on par with the Honda, Toyota, and Fords I have owned in the past
        normc32
        • 5 Months Ago
        @FRD
        Either would of thought of a KIA but took the Sportage for a drive even though they didn't have the 2.0T in stock. As soon as we pulled off the paved parking lot onto the road I was ready to turn around. It drove like and handled like an ox cart follow every grove in the road. So I BSed with the salesman abiur motorcycles foe the whole ride and purchased and Buick Encore. This car has warmed over many including my girlfriend who wanted to trade me her 2012 Forester straight up.
          FRD
          • 5 Months Ago
          @normc32
          Learn to spell Norm and maybe I will take you seriously.
      FIDTRO
      • 5 Months Ago
      If Kia was able to slip into the mix, some consumers must really not know what true quality is. Poor souls.
        creamwobbly
        • 5 Months Ago
        @FIDTRO
        I think it's funny that they named a soulless box "Soul". Also this: Key ass portage Key *******
      Zoom
      • 5 Months Ago
      If tesla can top this type of list, Volkswagen has no excuse.
        ravenosa
        • 5 Months Ago
        @Zoom
        Producing a lineup of cars that doesn't induce a coma would be a start for VW. Right now, going to their website is downright depressing...
          Bernard
          • 5 Months Ago
          @ravenosa
          VW doesn't like to update the engines in their vehicles. Furthermore, like most Euro brands the engines are built around engine displacement tax laws instead of things like performance, ease of maintenance, reliability, affordability, and driver enjoyment.
      Avinash Machado
      • 5 Months Ago
      All these conflicting survey's end up confusing the consumer.
        normc32
        • 5 Months Ago
        @Avinash Machado
        Most like my girlfriend just sees the survey that pads the car they like and stick with it. She liked the Motor Trend CUV of the year for 2014 Forestereven though the own 2012 and she knows It is a piece of junk compared to my Encore that she offered to trade for even swap
      SloopJohnB
      • 5 Months Ago
      Kudos to Audi for playing the gameā€¦but their multi-link front suspension with it's problematic upper control arm(s) is a constant source of aggravation after the Audi warranty has expired. I've had to replace both front UCAs on both V8 audis twice after 50K miles. The shocks also after 100K. Quality? Not so much after the warranty.
      TPGIII
      • 5 Months Ago
      One odd thing I see in this is that the C-Max Energi topped the Small Alternative Powertrain (APT) Car category, while the Volt tied for the top position in the Mid-Size Alternative Powertrain (APT) Car category. Yet the EPA puts the Volt as a Compact car car and the C-Max as a Midsize car. They are both on page 33 of the 2014 Fuel Economy Guide. I've been in both, and the C-Max is much larger in the passenger area, particularly the back seat. That aside, the C-Max had a higher score too.
      in2dwww
      • 5 Months Ago
      Yet it appears that the Mercedes SL took the highest score. That's interesting.
      bootsnchaps60
      • 5 Months Ago
      Maybe the Dart and Mirage were selected becaue they do a decent job of going from point A to B, which is what the majority of us do on a daily basis, without the added cost of the race/performance car fantasy/decoration. Does that make them the dreaded "A " word (appliances)? Probably, but I have better things to do with my money than pay Geico more for a high horsepower car.
    • Load More Comments