Let's start with the good news. On average, any new car you buy in the US today will be 43 percent cleaner than any average new car in 1998. Here's some more good news, for Korea anyway, Hyundai-Kia has been named the cleanest automaker in the latest study by the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS), which looked at 2013 model year vehicles sold between October 2012 and September 2013 from the top eight automakers (by volume). The bad news? The big three Detroit automakers are, on average, still making the dirtiest cars in the showroom.

The big three Detroit automakers are, on average, still making the dirtiest cars in the showroom.

The problem for Ford, General Motors and Chrysler lies in their trucks, which sell well but tend to have pretty bad fuel economy (compared to sedans, at least). The UCS calculates its list by averaging "the per-mile emissions for each light-duty vehicle sold by each automaker" and then factors in "the fuel economy, fuel type, and sales volume of each type of vehicle sold by each automaker" and "the upstream global warming emissions from producing and distributing the fuel used by each vehicle, as well as emissions from the vehicles themselves." That all means that, the more trucks you sell, the worse you're gonna do. Then again, the more trucks you sell with 18 mpg, the more you're helping drivers put CO2 into the air, so the UCS is doing a fair comparison of the things that this study is trying to track. More details on the methodology are available on page six of the study PDF.

In case you were wondering (we were), UCS did make sure to use the revised mpg numbers for Hyundai and Kia models that were originally overstated. Hyundai has apologized for and fixed those figures and even with the new, corrected numbers, Hyundai's total emissions are dropping at a rate of about three percent a year, enough for it to take the greenest company title for the first time.

In fact, this is the first time that an automaker other than Honda has come out on top in the UCS ranking, which has been released six times now, including the first one in 2000 (which looked at 1998 model year data). In 2010, Honda was almost knocked off the winner's perch by both Hyundai and Toyota, but managed to hold on. Chrysler, on the other hand, came in dead last (again) in the ranking of the top eight automakers, snagging the "dirtiest tailpipe" award once (again). Read the UCS' press release below.

We asked study author Dave Cooke what an automaker could do to improve its score, and he told AutoblogGreen in an email that:

Improving the fuel economy of a manufacturer's biggest sellers should be a top priority. However, boosting sales of a very green vehicle can help as well. For a good example of how both strategies would be helpful, you can look at Nissan-less than two percent of Nissan's sales are the Leaf, but since it performs so much better than the average vehicle, it is able to improve Nissan's score by one percent just by being sold. However, if you improved Nissan's top-selling vehicle, the Altima (~25 percent of sales), by about five percent, this would also give a similar level of improvement. By focusing on both improving its existing, popular vehicles and developing a "green" halo car, Nissan was able to make the most gains in reducing global warming emissions from its fleet since the last rankings.

Chrysler, you know what to do.
Show full PR text
New Ranking Shows All Major Auto Companies Boosted Green Performance

Hyundai-Kia Dethrones Honda to Become New Greenest Automaker

WASHINGTON (May 27, 2014) – The country's eight bestselling automakers are all improving their environmental performance thanks to new technologies and stronger standards for fuel efficiency and tailpipe emissions, according to the Union of Concerned Scientists' (UCS) latest Automaker Rankings report, which found that Hyundai-Kia has unseated Honda to become the group's new "Greenest Automaker."

For the first time since UCS began its Automaker Rankings report, all eight automakers reduced their average carbon and smog-forming emissions compared to their fleet averages from 1998, the model year examined in the first report. The report, the sixth evaluation of its kind by UCS, examined the emissions of both global warming and smog-forming pollution from 2013 model year vehicles of the automakers.

"For too many years, clean car standards were stagnant and automakers were more likely to promote extra cup holders instead of fuel economy," said Dave Cooke, a vehicles analyst in the Clean Vehicles Program and the author of the report. "Now, consumers are demanding cars that go further on a gallon of gas and new standards are pushing the automakers to deliver. The big lesson here is that the smog and global warming standards are working and there is much more to be gained as these standards progress."

Stronger tailpipe emissions standards have led to an 87 percent reduction in smog-forming tailpipe emissions from the average car or truck since 2000, while global warming emissions from the average vehicle have decreased by nearly 20 percent since 1998.

Using the adjusted, most up-to-date information on Hyundai-Kia's vehicles after the automaker had to revise its performance data with the U.S. EPA, the findings show that the automaker came out in first place thanks to a concerted effort to improve the green performance of its fleet by turbocharging and downsizing engines in a number of its models while also introducing hybrid-electric versions of two of its top-selling vehicles, the Hyundai Sonata and Kia Optima.

This report marks the first time another company has bested Honda, which came in second this year but has earned every "Greenest Automaker" previous accolade from UCS since 1998.

"Honda continues to lead the way in many vehicle classes, but it's started to lag the industry average in its midsize fleet-which includes its best-selling Accord, and accounts for a quarter of the company's sales," said Cooke. "As Hyundai-Kia works to further improve fuel economy and electrify its fleet, Honda will need to step up its game if it wants to take back the crown."

It was a three-way tie for third place, with Toyota, Nissan, and Volkswagen too close to call. While all the international automakers in the ranking scored better than the national average, the Detroit Three – Ford, General Motors, and Chrysler – continue to bring up the rear, as they have in every automaker ranking. However, some domestic automakers are making greater strides than others

Ford led the Detroit automakers while achieving the greatest percent reduction in smog-forming emissions of any manufacturer evaluated. The company also enjoyed strong improvements in global warming emissions due to its increased use of hybrids and its focus on smaller, turbocharged engines in vehicles ranging from the Ford Focus sedan to its iconic, best-selling large pick-up, the F-150, demonstrating that fuel-economy gains are possible across an automaker's entire fleet.

Technology will be crucial to achieving continued reductions in both global warming and smog-forming emissions from the U.S. fleet, the report projects, as more stringent emissions standards continue to take effect. Diverse strategies to improve fuel economy and global warming emissions-from improvements in conventional engines to plug-in-electric and hybrid-electric vehicles-all present opportunities for automakers to continue and accelerate the trend of reducing emissions across all types of vehicles.

"Automakers have a lot of clean technology ready to roll, and they are only just beginning to deploy it," said Don Anair, research director of the UCS Clean Vehicles program. "Continued investments by automakers coupled with strong performance standards will ensure new models further reduce fuel consumption and tailpipe emissions while offering the cleanest, most fuel-efficient vehicle choices for their customers."

The Union of Concerned Scientists puts rigorous, independent science to work to solve our planet's most pressing problems. Joining with citizens across the country, we combine technical analysis and effective advocacy to create innovative, practical solutions for a healthy, safe, and sustainable future.


I'm reporting this comment as:

Reported comments and users are reviewed by Autoblog staff 24 hours a day, seven days a week to determine whether they violate Community Guideline. Accounts are penalized for Community Guidelines violations and serious or repeated violations can lead to account termination.


    • 1 Second Ago
  • 182 Comments
      BipDBo
      • 6 Months Ago
      This is an odd coincidence. The greenest companies also are the ones that sell almost all no-fun appliance cars.
        jonnybimmer
        • 6 Months Ago
        @BipDBo
        Why do people always forget Hyundai makes the Genesis Coupe? I know it's generally not the sport coupe people care for and it could be accurately described as lacking the personality/dynamics that other cars like Miatas, FRS, etc. have, but credit where credit is due; enthusiasts had been demanding a cheap RWD coupe and they delivered with one that even has bare-basics version with 6 speed manual, Brembo brakes and turbo 4 cylinder. The styling might still be Hyundai weird, but they put their money where their mouth is better than a few other companies out there (ahem, Honda/Scion)
          jonnybimmer
          • 6 Months Ago
          @jonnybimmer
          @BipDBo Sorry, my selective reading kicked in and neglected the "almost". I agree though, the Mustang and Camaro are in a higher league though to be fair, they've both been around for nearly 50 years. Hyundai went in without really knowing where it stood in the market (pretty much only had the Z to directly compete against) and unfortunately for them, just happened to be at a time when the other two seriously stepped up their game.
          BipDBo
          • 6 Months Ago
          @jonnybimmer
          I didn't forget. The Genesis Coupe and the sedan are both good cars. The Genesis coupe, though, IMO, lags behind the Mustang and Camaro. But I said "almost all". The rest of their lineup are purely appliances.
      Spec
      • 6 Months Ago
      I think that Hyundai should have been disqualified for their EPA MPG ratings shenanigans.
      Matt
      • 6 Months Ago
      I would say this would be much more useful if they separated cars and trucks. Yes, the big three might still be at the bottom since they still make multiple models with 8 cylinders, but it would show that the companies are much closer than this study makes you believe.
      James
      • 6 Months Ago
      I am pretty sure I remember hearing that Mazda had the highest average MPG of any automaker... was there a caveat to that statement?
      Jim
      • 6 Months Ago
      It is worth pointing out that "green" companies Nissan and Toyota also make gas-guzzling full-size trucks. They just can't sell any.
      Mark Schaffer
      • 6 Months Ago
      As an exercise this morning on our commute to my wife's workplace we will count the number of pristine condition trucks with one person commuting to their workplaces.
      Alfonso T. Alvarez
      • 6 Months Ago
      @ 2 wheeled menace "Yes, those priuses the greenies are driving just blow smoke all over da place." You mean this Piouss that are all built in Japan and then shipped here on freighters that use bunker oil for fuel, the dirtiest, nastiest most polluting transportation method? Yeah, they sure are 'green' ...
      czarkzm
      • 6 Months Ago
      Sadly this is just another 1/2 story from the modern cadre of "environmental" writers. I know plenty of people who drive trucks (often for work) but have a much smaller overall environmental footprint than the loud mouthed self proclaimed environmentalists. These are the same fools who go on about their low MPG from the soapbox on top of their over climate controlled McMansion which is full of crap made overseas in factories with little or no environmental controls, and then shipped across the ocean in cargo ships, and then trucked across the country with a rate of fuel consumption that more than destroys the higher mileage they get on their short daily commute. Time to start thinking big picture here folks....I realize its easy to wrap a bow around a story on fuel consumption and keep it under 1,000 words for the blogosphere but pollution is a bigger issue than vehicles, and while they are a significant contributor it's time to start educating consumers on the broader aspects of environmental living.
      jesscott
      • 6 Months Ago
      Lets see an info-graphic/article about how far Trucks have progressed over the last 10 years. Things like weight loss, drive line changes and percentage mpg gains. I hate to see trucks taking a beating for being environmentally destructive when they have come so far and will always be a necessity. They aren't what they are being painted to be.
      EVSUPERHERO
      • 6 Months Ago
      They would make a more efficient PU if you people would demand it. Instead you all spend time protecting them for their 100 year old inefficient technology. Get a grip man. Eco boost bull ain't gonna cut it. Demand they put the Voltec technology in your urban PU ala Via Motors.
      Cruising
      • 6 Months Ago
      But, but cars like the Corvette or trucks like the Ram Eco Diesel are making great strides in fuel economy numbers. That's really exciting from a engineering standpoint.
        Corey Blue
        • 2 Days Ago
        @Cruising
        But to to the stupid greenies fuel mileage does not equal green-ness. That's the hypocrisy in the whole deal.
      EVSUPERHERO
      • 6 Months Ago
      Just admit it, their bad, um kay. Gas cars are bad, umkay. Oil is bad, umkay. Oil is a drug umkay, drugs are bad umkay. Your all addicted umkay.
    • Load More Comments