• Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
  • Image Credit: Sebastian Blanco
One of the more popular US college basketball cheers takes place when a visiting superstar player has a sub-par performance and the student section cheers "OVER-RATED" followed by a rhythmic five-clap. The concept has apparently made its way overseas to a UK journalist reviewing BMW's new i3 plug-in vehicle.

The Telegraph rated the i3 three out of five stars, even while calling it "a delight to drive."

While acknowledging the many very positive reviews for the all-electric version (ours from last month would certainly qualify), the reviewer for UK's Telegraph found plenty of things to quibble about when it came to the i3 and its 650-cc gas-powered range extender. Not only did the Bimmer have less-than-advertised range on both its electric motor and the range extender, but the car's control system, which restricts power when the battery charge gets low before the generator kicks in, limited the i3 to dangerously slow (by highway standards) speeds. Between those factors and the car's relatively small trunk, the Telegraph rated the i3 three out of five stars, even while calling it "a delight to drive."

In general the car, sans the gas-powered range extender, has been praised for its roominess, quickness and regenerative braking system, among other things, but most of the early journalist drives were done in battery-only vehicles. On top of the gas-burning option, BMW is trying to get prospective buyers to take the plunge by offering a full suite of services ranging from free consultation for at-home charging station installations to ChargeNow cards to an on-board navigation system that helps locate nearby public charging stations. We hope they work better than the Telegraph's experience with the REx. Check out the video below.


Autoblog accepts vehicle loans from auto manufacturers with a tank of gas and sometimes insurance for the purpose of evaluation and editorial content. Like most of the auto news industry, we also sometimes accept travel, lodging and event access for vehicle drive and news coverage opportunities. Our opinions and criticism remain our own — we do not accept sponsored editorial.

I'm reporting this comment as:

Reported comments and users are reviewed by Autoblog staff 24 hours a day, seven days a week to determine whether they violate Community Guideline. Accounts are penalized for Community Guidelines violations and serious or repeated violations can lead to account termination.


    • 1 Second Ago
  • From Our Partners

    2017 BMW X3
    MSRP: $38,950 - $47,650
    2017 BMW X4
    MSRP: $45,250 - $57,800
    2016 BMW 228
    MSRP: $32,850 - $40,650
    2016 BMW X6
    MSRP: $60,600 - $75,300
    2016 BMW X5
    MSRP: $54,700 - $71,500
    Share This Photo X