Review: A different take on Challenger vs. Camaro
A different take on Challenger vs. Camaro – Click above for high-res image gallery
The original ponycar wars have boomeranged back after forty years. Ford started it all with a retro-tasty Mustang, and Dodge and Chevrolet have rolled out new versions of the Challenger and Camaro to get in on the frenzy. Looking at the window sticker of any of these cars may seriously depress you. Your retired boomer Dad could swing it as a way to recapture the time before his potential was all used up, but you're not going to step into one of these things if the ink on your diploma has been dry for less than a year.
We have uncovered a way for anyone to get their hands on a Camaro for a price that would please even your paperboy. Better yet, it comes with its own instructional course, so you know what the heck you're doing. It's not exactly a Camaro of the vehicular variety, but HSN's limited-edition Esteban Camaro guitar (almost sold out!) can grab attention in its own right. What's more, those halcyon days of carburetors and bias ply tires are at your fingertips – classic rock tablature abounds. We figured that we'd try out the guitar with the potential to make you a rock star and compare and contrast it with the Dodge Challenger SRT8, a vehicle that nudges the driver that much closer to being chased by paparazzi. Think it's an even, if category-bending matchup? Hit the jump to find out.
Photos copyright ©2009 Dan Roth / Weblogs, Inc.
Looks:
Both the Camaro and the Challenger sport shades of red broken up by sporty striping. The Challenger's body sculpting is and always will be beautiful. The original Challenger lines have been carefully adapted to a much larger platform with excellent results. We've been worried lately that Chrysler's needle has skipped out of its storied styling groove, but the Challenger's bodywork proves that Auburn Hills can still do it.

Thankfully, only the guitar has a mural painted on its back side, no 1970s-throwback screaming chickens on the MoPar. Both are limited editions, as well, though we didn't find a numbered plaque on the Challenger, the Esteban Camaro that HSN gracefully provided to us is number 7,625 of 25,000. It sports a single cut-away neck, a nod to being able to tear it up on rock leads, and the size is comfortable. At the top of the headstock is a Chevrolet bowtie, and the fretboard is inlaid with faux mother of pearl lettering that spells out CAMARO. Overall, the automotive detailing on the guitar is subtle.
Power:
Hemi. Six-point-one liters. It says so right on the hood, what more do you need to know? The modern Chrysler HEMI is one of the best V8 engines, bar none. Power is there right up to redline, and the sound that bellows from the twin box-tips out back is second only to hearing your child's first cries. The rhythm and roar of a V8 certainly pairs well with a 1-4-5 chord progression.




The guitar has a piezoelectric pickup and a preamplifier sporting three-band EQ and a volume knob. The single TS jack isn't as cool as the Challenger's dual exhaust, but having an active preamp allows you to supercharge your sound by plugging into your favorite amplifier. In light of the way the Challenger can roast its tires, we figured a Smoky Amp would be a good fit, and when we wanted finer control, we found a variety of colors available by using a Vox Brian May amp that was on hand.
Handling:
Both the Esteban Camaro and the Challenger SRT have light controls. There's much more tactile feedback from the guitar than is offered up by the Challenger's steering wheel. Overall, it seems that the Challenger, while capable of hooning, is very well suited to laying back and cruising as well - playing rhythm, if you will. A sixth gear that puts 70mph highway cruise down in the 2,000 rpm realm makes for a car with long legs, and the comfortable surroundings aid and abet drivers wanting to try a Cannonball.


While the Esteban will allow you to go as fast as your fingers can handle, there are definite dynamic limits to the Challenger. In terms of unlimited performance potential, the guitar has it all over the car. Sound is easily variable, too, just by changing up strings - a lot faster than taking the motor apart and twiddling with it. The neck of the guitar fits many hands easily, though the strings are spaced a little closely down at the far end. The most perfect control out of either of these is the Challenger's shifter. An ergonomic masterpiece, the throwback pistol-grip fits just right, and it doesn't hurt that the rest of the transmission operates slickly and teams with a forgiving clutch.
Price:
And here's the rub. The Challenger SRT: $45,000. The Esteban Camaro: $239.95 with a gig bag, chord chart, picks, strap, and a 10 DVD instructional video series. Automakers could learn a thing or two from HSN, as well. We called to try this guitar out and in 2 days it was sitting on our porch.

GM is backed up pretty solidly trying to fill orders on the Camaro, so some people will be waiting until next year to take delivery. While certainly not an apples to apples comparison, at least HSN makes it possible for you to own a $300 Camaro without it meaning a rusty beast with Flinstone floors and rod knock audible into the next county.
Photos copyright ©2009 Dan Roth / Weblogs, Inc.














Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Taglane 12:04PM (9/18/2009)
I totally have this guitar. Except the lettering says "CANARO" like wtf:
http://i237.photobucket.com/albums/ff22/Hakem1125/PICT1364.jpg?t=1253289810
Still cool though.
Reply
Commander Cool 12:08PM (9/18/2009)
You forgot one crucial comparison:
Both will get you babes, but only the Challenger will allow you to take them with you.
Reply
MikeInNC 11:44AM (9/19/2009)
Hey Commander Cool....if an Esteban gets you a girl...you're hanging out with the wrong girls. As a car enthusiast and guitar super-freak Esteban is the joke of the six string world. You can buy better for half the price and that isn't saying much.
Farris 12:11PM (9/18/2009)
This article actually points out something that I never really thought of: Back in the day, a Mustang was CHEAP and that was part of it's appeal, IIRC. (Granted I wasn't there, having been born 20 years late.) $2368 base price according to Google.
Now the cheapest one is what, $21k? Other than the obvious (more power, more safety, etc), what is the cause of the increase in price?
Reply
Farris 12:12PM (9/18/2009)
Oops, that was supposed to include some references to prices of other muscle cars. Oh well.
Sean 12:18PM (9/18/2009)
Still $1k+ cheaper than the base Camaro and Challenger, though.
drolds1 12:23PM (9/18/2009)
You're kidding, right?
While you were Googling, did you also look up what the average salary was in 1964 as compared to 2009. Try "inflation" as well.
Big Mola 12:23PM (9/18/2009)
Econo-cars start in the mid to high-teens nowadays, unless you go for the stripper trim. So $20K seems reasonable for a "muscle" car.
And, @Sean--You get what you pay for ;)
Brian 12:23PM (9/18/2009)
Nostalgic baby boomers who want to re-live their "youth" (even though they probably drove a Pinto back in the day), that's what.
Patrick 12:26PM (9/18/2009)
Um gas was $.05/gallon, you could let your toddlers walk to pre school alone and wives stayed at home.
Basically, who doesn't wish they lived in the 60s? Lol.
Brian 12:30PM (9/18/2009)
Well, Patrick, there was that whole "Vietnam" episode (you may have heard of it) and inner-city riots. Oh, and assassinations. But besides that, yeah...great time.
Patrick 1:14PM (9/18/2009)
Brian, yeah those aspects were no good. Wow I'm proud to have a decent conversation with you for once. And to Farris. You're a tool. Take Econ, Finance and history when you're old enough to go to school.
Samurai Jack 6:07PM (9/18/2009)
Hey Patrick... I wager anyone who isn't white/Caucasian would be willing to give the '60's a pass too...
Farris 7:26PM (9/18/2009)
I'm a tool? Really?
I was just asking a question. My apologies if that offended you.
I was just referencing the fact that cars used to be a lot cheaper back in the day.
For the record, I'm 21 and an Electrical Engineering major. I'll be sure to obtain your approval before I post next time.
Big Mola 12:26PM (9/18/2009)
@Brian,
That's how life works, unless you're born with a silver spoon in your mouth. Work hard and then you get to buy the toys you wanted but couldn't afford in your youth.
Unless you do it bass-ackward like a someone I know: College-dropout cell phone salesman who bought a brand new BMW.
Reply
Moe 12:41PM (9/18/2009)
Seriously? What a waste of time.
Reply
Dan Roth 1:20PM (9/18/2009)
Hey, you didn't have to read it
Tony 1:00PM (9/18/2009)
What next, Mustang Sally's? Challenger space shuttles? Camaro corn removers?
Reply
Visnick 1:12PM (9/18/2009)
What lens was used to take these?
Reply
Dan Roth 1:20PM (9/18/2009)
Nikon 50mm f1.4 on a D50 body (so, with the D50's 1.5 crop, it was a 75)