Driven: Subaru Forester XTI concept, WRX and WRX STI with SPT mods

Subaru Forester XTI concept, WRX and STI with SPT mods – Click above for high-res image gallery
Subaru invited us out to the track to sample some of its Subaru Performance Tuning (SPT) components, fitted to the company's Forester XTI show car, as well as the Impreza WRX and STI models. While we applaud any manufacturer that engineers a line of factory-approved aftermarket parts, we hand out additional kudos to the few who welcome us to a local racing circuit to put them to the fire. What add-ons did Subaru bring to Willow Springs, and how did they perform on the track? Come with us to find out...
Gallery: Subaru WRX with SPT
Photos Copyright ©2009 Michael Harley / Weblogs, Inc., Subaru North America
Subaru STI Performance Parts are found in a glossy 18-page catalog chock-full of short throw shifters, strut braces, exhaust systems, cold air intakes, transmission mounts, boost gauges, and more. Of course, one will also find the obligatory cosmetic carbon fiber add-ons, STI mugs, and Subaru-branded golf balls. While most of the parts are covered under the factory limited warranty, some of them are only covered under the limited parts warranty, and a few are sold "as-is" without any warranty covered (those are typically designed for "off-highway" or race applications only).

To give us an excellent back-to-back comparison between a stock and an SPT modified vehicle, Subaru brought four cars to the Streets of Willow Springs race track, located just outside the town of Rosamond in the California desert. There were two Impreza WRX models (one stock and one modified), and two Impreza WRX STI models (one stock and one modified). As an unexpected cherry on this ice cream sundae of an afternoon, Subaru also brought out its one-of-a-kind Forester XTI concept for its track debut. That's right, the SEMA show car custom-fitted with full STI running gear!
2009 Forester XTI (Concept)
- 2.5-liter turbocharged boxer flat-four
- Est. 315 hp / 300 lb-ft
- Six-speed manual
- Dunlop SP Sport 600 – Max Performance Summer Tires (200 A A)

As a one-off concept, we were understandably apprehensive about tossing this particular Forester into the corners at speed. To our amazement, however, it handled the circuit like a true champ. Entering the turns, the compact SUV displayed initial turn-in that inspired confidence (the underpinnings are slightly modified from the STI, not mirrored). While credit may go to the additional weight over the front end, that same mass becomes a slight penalty while exiting the sharper corners which took all 315 horses to get back to speed. We didn't push it that hard, but overall the XTI was balanced and easy to drive without any glaring shortcomings. Subaru's so-called "tarmac monster" delivered as promised. Now, we want to see it in the showroom!
2009 Impreza WRX four-door sedan (stock)
- 2.5-liter turbocharged boxer flat-four
- 265 hp / 244 lb-ft
- Five-speed manual
- Dunlop SP Sport 01 – Ultra High Performance Summer Tires (280 A A)

While the bone-stock Subaru WRX is a ton of fun as a daily driver on public roads, but when the new body style debuted, it simply became too domesticated for proper showroom-to-track duty. In fact, its inadequacies – starting with the suspension – surface in the first corner. When really pushed, the tallish ride height leads to pronounced body roll. The stock WRX suspension is soft and the body tends to float rather than settle down. The shift in weight unloads the inside tires and strips them of their contact patches. Pushed harder, the stock WRX will plow as the front outside tire is completely overworked. Adding power simply increases the tire howl without any significant directional change. Lacking firm suspension while sliding on street tires, the best way to recover is to get off the gas, wait for the vehicle to dump weight back on the inside springs, and then use the all-wheel drive grip to hustle the car around the corner. Driven at 8/10ths, and with weight transfer a mental priority, the stock WRX is safe and predictable... just not a slot-car ride on a track.
2009 Impreza WRX Five-Door (SPT modifications)
- 2.5-liter turbocharged flat-four boxer
- 265 hp / 244 lb-ft
- Five-speed manual
- Dunlop SP Sport 01 – Ultra High Performance Summer Tires (280 A A)
- STI Lip Spoiler
- STI Shift Knob 5MT
- STI Short Throw 5MT
- STI Shifter Bushing
- Strut Tower Brace
- Chassis Brace
- SPT Performance Exhaust 5D

The stock five-speed transmission feels great... until you try the short throw set-up. Then, you quickly realize how much it improves shift throw and feel without adding unnecessary effort or making the transmission feel too mechanical. We like it. Under the skin, this WRX is fitted with chassis reinforcements, but really no other suspension modifications. It also wears a throaty SPT stainless exhaust system. There must be some "mental horsepower" with the new exhaust, because the aggressive sound caused us to push this car much harder than the stock WRX on the track.
Seat of the pants, the chassis did feel a bit better, but lacking any direct suspension upgrades we found ourselves plowing and sliding into the corners yet again. Interestingly enough, something else surfaced: Driven at 9/10ths, our higher speeds were really starting to destroy the single-piston brakes. The stock pads were overheating and the rotors were getting chewed-up. Even worse, we noticed that heavy brake applications above 90 mph would invoke immediate ABS. With the wheels clawing for traction, the WRX would become uncomfortably unsettled on the stock suspension. While the short throw shifter and new exhaust was welcomed, we think the chassis-bracing modifications were a bit out of order – our money would focus on calming the struts, sways, and springs first, along with a new set of brake pads.
2009 Impreza WRX STI five-door (stock)
- 2.5-liter turbocharged flat-four boxer
- 305 hp / 290 lb-ft
- Six-speed manual
- Dunlop SP Sport 600 – Max Performance Summer Tires (200 A A)

The stock STI was immediately a noticeable improvement over both WRX models. With additional power, a more advanced AWD system (including the Driver Controlled Center Differential), and Brembo brakes, we were able to push it hard on the track. In stock showroom form, the high-performance STI still exhibited noticeable body roll and would eventually understeer, but after a few laps, it became easy to predict exactly how the vehicle would react. While we were absolutely killing the stock street tires, and the brake pads weren't up to heavy track duty, it was apparent that your Average Joe could hit the local circuit in a stock STI and spend his day plastered with a big grin.
2009 Impreza WRX STI five-door (SPT modifications)
- 2.5-liter turbocharged flat-four boxer
- 305 hp / 290 lb-ft
- Six-speed manual
- Dunlop SP Sport 600 – Max Performance Summer Tires (200 A A)
- STI Lip Spoiler
- STI Shift Knob 6MT
- STI Short Throw 6MT
- STI Shifter Bushing
- SPT Strut Tower Brace
- SPT Chassis Brace
- STI Pink Springs
- SPT Performance Exhaust System 5D

What a difference some good suspension tuning makes. This STI was fitted with the 6MT short-throw shifter and stainless exhaust. Both are must-have items that really complement the personality of this high-performance vehicle without sacrificing ride quality or comfort. Under the skin, the modified STI was equipped with chassis braces and new springs, lowering the ride height and firming things up.
On the race circuit, this STI was clearly top dog. It was incredibly stable in the corners – almost neutral – and we could really use its power to our advantage on the exits. Again, the tires and brake pads were the weak links, but those are both easy aftermarket fixes. This STI was outfitted very well for a combo daily driver/track role, as it never felt abusive or harsh in our hands (as dedicated track cars often do). With a set of R-compound tires and some race pads slipped into the meaty Brembo calipers, a vehicle configured like this STI would eat more than its share of competitors on the race circuit.




Bred on the competitive World Rally Championship circuit, the WRX and STI both offer an impressive amount of street performance straight out of the box. The track is a whole different animal, as was evident by the abuse the street tires and brake pads were taking on all of the vehicles (if you are going to regularly track any vehicle, do yourself a favor and invest in the proper tires and pads first). Competition consumables aside, there are countless aftermarket options when modifying an Impreza. And with factory engineering and designs proven in professional racing, Subaru owners would do well to check out the comprehensive list of SPT offerings.
Gallery: Subaru WRX with SPT
Photos Copyright ©2009 Michael Harley / Weblogs, Inc., Subaru North America








Get a WordPress.com Blog




Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
Victor 12:09PM (4/24/2009)
Bring in the forester XTi!
Reply
Victor 12:15PM (4/24/2009)
upon further reading of your assessment of the WRX and STi. I have to say that suspension quibbles can be pretty easily addressed with some parts swapped out. Although, I must say; the current assessment you have of the WRX's track abilities are pretty much on target. They are a bit better than 08's. Here's to hoping to-be-wifey will let me get the STi, as she takes over my current Suby!
blotto 12:32PM (4/24/2009)
Me wants Forester XTI!
Man, it'll be a perfect sleeper car ready for bumper stickers like:
"You've been beat by a CUV!" (can't really say "station wagon" any more with the new redesign)
"Subaru Forester - Fast groceries!"
"Subaru Forester - Hauls more than ass"
chconline 12:56PM (4/24/2009)
REAL sleepers don't dress it up with lame bumper stickers :P
Abe 12:12PM (4/24/2009)
Mechanically they're solid machines and performers, and I'm sure the higher end versions are amazing to drive, with the exception of the previous gen Legacy, their designs completely lacks any character. Even the Corolla has more design personality inside-out.
Reply
Rev 11:14AM (4/25/2009)
I feel the same way about Audis.
Compared to many other autos (especially from Japan) I'd have to wholeheartedly disagree about Subarus. Most Japanese cars tend to look like generic appliances (though the new Mazda3 looks like an appliance with a smiley face) ~ this looks like a Subaru: funky, European meets Japanese exterior. Looks all business to me (especially the STI). The 5-door is one of my favorite hatches on the road. You want boring? Take a look at the GTI. I would definitely take a Corolla over a Rabbit, no doubt.
I'm not seeing what you're talking about with the Corolla compared to the WRX/STI. Perhaps you're a Toyota fan?
Abe 2:06PM (4/25/2009)
Actually I'm not really a Toyota fan, I appreciate some of their products but they're still the appliance leaders of the industry. I was implying that the mundane Corolla does have a little more design character than most new Subarus. I'm just not a big fan of Subaru's new designs. I feel the opposite about Audis and Mazdas, I think that they are the best designed cars in their respective categories.
xtasi 12:14PM (4/24/2009)
I don't like how Subaru boast it's rally heritage and track performance, adds factory approved performance parts but, if you take it to a track, warranty is void. So, I need 300+ hp for going to work, in traffic???? and the trick SI drive? must help a lot in stop and go traffic.
Reply
BoxerFanatic 2:34PM (4/24/2009)
I do use 300hp in my commuter. My stage 2 Legacy GT. It is nice. It also gets 26mpg on the highway...
SI-drive is somewhat gimmicky, but if you aren't pushing, "I" mode is supposed to tame down the response, and get better mileage, with full power and quicker throttle, at the turn of a knob, or press of a button on the steering wheel.
The SAD part is, those features are GONE from the 2010 Legacy, it appears.
SI-Drive gone.
Rear Limited Slip gone.
Fog lights gone.
folding signal mirrors gone.
good styling gone.
lithe and attractive size gone.
nice electroluminescent guages gone.
nice straightforward center console design gone.
Outback XT Gone.
Legacy GT with automatic gone, manual only, and probably quite small fraction of production, as it already was.
Spec B model is gone, although now GT has 6 gears, so makes it a bit redundant...
Replaced with bigger, bulkier uglier design, inside and out, for the Legacy.
Bigger, bulkier may have worked for the Forester. It is an SUV, which can be good to look bulkier and more truck-like.
But the hunchback, er, hatchback Impreza is ugly and flat-faced. the new Legacy and outback are not as attractive, or even as well equipped as their outgoing predecessors.
Sorry, Subaru. You don't get to try to foist a "Sporty" Forester, in place of handicapping the Legacy lineup.
Just further supports my theory, that the people who do product planning for Japan, where Impreza and Forester lines are built, are much different in intention than the product planners for the US-made US-market Legacy, Outback, and Tribeca. The JDM Legacy and Outback will probably continue to offer more of an option list, and a larger model catalog.
fixitfixitstop 10:21AM (4/30/2009)
Subaru isn't the only brand which advertises capabilities which would void warranties.
B_O_T 12:19PM (4/24/2009)
Awesome post!
The Forester XT STI would be a sweet machine if they ever produced some.
Reply
B_O_T 12:20PM (4/24/2009)
*XTI
Franz 12:34PM (4/24/2009)
Yeah, the old Forrester STIs were a riot. Drove just like a slightly bigger Impreza STI.
Hugh G 12:20PM (4/24/2009)
I was really close to getting an STI, but then decided on an '09 Mazdaspeed 3. It was just the better choice considering the roughly $15,000 price difference. So far, I love the MS3 and will probably leave it bone stock...its plenty fast and handles great. If I want, I can perform a couple mods from Cobb Tuning and get STI type performance out of it...probably for under $2K. I don't think there is any better performance bargain on the market than the MS3.
Now, if I had to do it over again...and the economy were doing better... I'd probably go with a 370Z....love that car.
Reply
Ligor 12:25PM (4/24/2009)
ditto on the 370Z
but the MS3 will always suffer to the STi as the AWD system makes the STI a monster in any weather - bar none. but it's too ugly to be my ride even so.
havoc 12:28PM (4/24/2009)
cobb cobb cobb
AP tuner, SRI and cat-back.
the AP tuner can remove the boost cut and increase boost (besides other things like timing and fuel trim). AP tuner also includes low-boost and valet modes, which might be useful for city driving.
Cobb is known for their suby work too, so this isn't completely irrelevant
jakecarolan 12:45PM (4/24/2009)
Just wondering, why didn't you go with the WRX? The '09 offers pretty similar performance/tunability to the MS3.
That said, I agree with your assessment that the MS3 is the best performance bargain on the market, though the Cobalt SS provides some solid bang-for-buck competition at the 22-23k price range.
shinobemon 6:25PM (4/28/2009)
15k price difference? I got my 08 STI for 27k, just about 30k OTD. new. With 0% financing for 63 months.
I was eyeballing the MS3 for half a year as the STI was way out of my price range...Sometimes it pays to wait :)
Tomac 12:28PM (4/24/2009)
The Forester XTI would certainly be sweet. I'm hauling around three sub-kindergarteners though, so I'm holding my breath for Mazda to drop the Mazdaspeed3's drivetrain and suspension mods into the Mazda5. I wouldn't mind three rows and sliding side doors if I were rowing my own gears to the tune of 260hp.
Reply
havoc 12:31PM (4/24/2009)
Car and Driver had a blurb a few months back about a school swapping the MS3 drivetrain into a 5. the 5 is a good mini-minivan, almost like the pacifica with it's 2+2+2 seating, but just looks too pontiac transport-ish for me still.
Reply