Parents Television Council shakes finger at GM, Nissan over advertising

Those Chastity Pariahs over at the Parents Television Council have called out General Motors and Nissan, among others, for advertising on shows deemed shocking and outrageous. The PTC has ranked the best and worst companies based on the television programs they advertise on, arguing that the advertisers' support is tacit enabling of programming's content. It could be that the auto companies have advertising agencies that do smart things such as market research to determine where the target customer's eyeballs hang out. The PTC is all in a tizzy over GM ads shown during Family Guy breaks, a show which is clearly satire and not intended for children, despite being animation. Nissan and GM spots showed up on shows that caused the PTC's red light to flash nearly 1,000 times during the last year, which shouldn't be correlated to bad behavior on the automakers' part, like the PTC would have you believe. Car companies are in the business of selling products to people; many people don't limit their viewing to Higglytown Heroes, some of whom occasionally purchase automobiles. Besides, what parent in their right mind would let a child watch Family Guy, with its decidedly blue and often hilarious content? Lighten up, Francis.
[Source: AdAge]
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
November 24, 2008
PTC Singles Out Best and Worst TV Advertisers
Calls on Holiday Shoppers to Support Responsible Companies
LOS ANGELES (November 24, 2008) – The Parents Television Council™ released its annual ranking of the "Top Ten Best and Worst Advertisers." The report ranked television advertisers from best to worst according to content in the prime time broadcast television programs they chose to underwrite. Advertisers that landed on the best list primarily sponsored family-friendly television shows, while those on the worst list often supported programs containing graphic sexual content, excessive violence or profanity.
"The role that television advertisers play in determining what type of content comes into every home in America cannot be overstated. We commend the advertisers on our best list that have chosen to associate their hard-earned corporate brands with positive programming that the entire family can watch together. Coca-Cola soared to the top of our best list after ranking ninth last year and Hewlett-Packard also began carefully evaluating the programming it underwrites to secure a place on our best list for the first time," said PTC President Tim Winter.
"By contrast, parents can thank many of the advertisers on the worst list for enabling the networks to pump some of the most shocking and outrageous content on the air today directly into their living rooms. Our top offenders include General Motors, which advertised on one of the most shocking episodes of Fox's 'Family Guy,' and Nissan, which helped pay for the bloodiest episode in the 'Dexter' series to air on broadcast television. In the 2007-2008 TV season alone, these two advertisers showed up nearly 1,000 times on 'red light' shows that are unsuitable for children according to PTC's traffic light ratings system.
"During the holiday season, we call on our members and all concerned citizens to carefully consider which companies they will support with their shopping dollars. While Kohl's and Target landed on our worst list, Wal-Mart barely missed the cut off for our best list and is to be lauded for its commitment to families. It is up to consumers to show companies that supporting family-friendly programming makes good businesses sense. The PTC will continue to encourage corporate responsibility for advertising buys and ask consumers to do the same by reinforcing that message with their wallets," Winter concluded.
Top Ten Best and Worst Advertisers
The PTC's list of the "Top Ten Best and Worst Advertisers" is based on each company's prime time network television ad buys during the 2007-2008 television season. Each company listed purchased at least 25 ads on prime time broadcast programs. Companies with the most ads on green light shows, based on PTC's trademarked traffic-light ratings system, were ranked the best, while companies with the most ads on red light shows were ranked the worst. PTC "campaign shows," which consistently feature problematic sexual, violent or profane content, were given special weight. To see each prime time show's rating, please visit http://www.parentstv.org/PTC/familyguide/main.asp.
BEST
1. Coca-Cola
2. The Clorox Company
3. Century 21 Real Estate LLC
4. H&R Block, Inc.
5. Ferrero S.p.A. (U.S.A.)
6. CVS Caremark Corporation
7. Whirlpool Corporation
8. The Hershey Company
9. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co.
10. Hewlett-Packard Company
WORST
1. General Motors Corporation
2. Nissan North America, Inc.
3. L'Oreal USA, Inc.
4. Pepsi-Cola North America
5. GlaxoSmithKline Holdings (Americas) Inc.
[Brands include: Beano, Lowerthepain.com, Os-Cal, Nicoderm, Sensodyne,
Valtrex, Advair, Aquafresh, and Myalli.com]
6. Reckitt Benckiser, Inc.
[Brand: Delsym]
7. Target Corporation
8. Kohl's Corporation
9. Verizon Communications, Inc.
10. Toyota Motor North America.







Get a WordPress.com Blog




Reader Comments (Page 1 of 5)
Ben 10:37AM (12/01/2008)
What....
...evar.
Reply
robz4 11:58AM (12/01/2008)
Giggity !
Ligor 12:49PM (12/01/2008)
stupid retards
last I checked, no one under 16 years old can drive (at least in MI) or buy their own car - so needles to pooint out the car commercials are for the adults that buy them
how stupid cna we get in this country
Rogue_G 10:41AM (12/01/2008)
Best? Coca Cola
Worst? GM
Irrelevant? Priceless.
Reply
AZZO45b 12:03PM (12/01/2008)
Best List: Coca Cola
Worst List: Pepsi Cola
BOTH rot kids teeth... so why are they on separate lists??? :) :) :)
Foose1397 10:42AM (12/01/2008)
Um last time i check it really is only adults buying cars???...
Oh and dexter is a damn good show so why not help. Is it just me or do some people/organization just like to complain and ruin the fun for everyone
Reply
Davin Black 10:48AM (12/01/2008)
It's definitely NOT just you.
I remember the uproar about the GM commercial showing a kid taking his dad's Corvette out for a spin, and PTC was in a tizzy about it. They take things waaay too seriously.
Davin Black 10:49AM (12/01/2008)
Relevant commercial: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z4YAt0GFsZU
Stéphane Dumas 11:17AM (12/01/2008)
@Davin Black
I agree with you about the PTC taking things too seriously, if they don't allow kids to dream, the PTC had gone nuts!
skeaping of the banned Corvette ad featuring a kid at the wheels, here a older ad from Brazil, featuring a Brazilian Ford model, the Corcel doing some stunts with kids who imagine doing some rally racing
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ODQHTtnlDqU
I wonder if a member of the PTC might do an heart attack if he see this old ad?
h8rain 11:12AM (12/01/2008)
That is exactly what I was thinking. A company that sells product to *only* adults (say 17+) advertises on shows that *only* adults (again 17+) should watch. Big F-ing shocker there.....
On the flip side, would the PTC get their panties in a knot if Viarga or Trojan was advertising on "good" programming? To answer that, YES they would, because those are adult products and should be advertised on adult programming.
Judy Zik 1:53PM (12/01/2008)
Why is it that some parents think we need to coat the whole world in Nerf and sanitize everything on the planet. Seems to me there used to be something called a Mommy and a Daddy and they used to actually take an interest in what little Timmy or Sally was doing and control their access to things that aren't safe or appropriate. This is just lazy parenting. Dexter is one of the best shows on TV but it airs long past your child's bedtime and if you let them watch it then you are a freak.
So just what action would this parents council like "responsible parents" to take to support this conclusion? Show their support by buying more Coke and Hershey products so their kids can grow up fat and lazy too. Oh and don't even think about quiting smoking since Nicoderm comes from an evil company too.
StinkyPete 10:50AM (12/01/2008)
So everyone that advertises during the Super Bowl must the devil in their eyes.
It's all about knowing your market. I wouldn't see any GM ads if they decided to pull out of the prime time markets. Interesting to not see McDonnald's on the "10 best" list, you know how 'the clown' loves kids.
Though GM could save some money for air time during children's programming.
Reply
Red 10:51AM (12/01/2008)
My ex used to let her kids watch Family Guy. I never watched an episode until I dated her. I'm no prude by any means, but I was kind of appalled she'd let her 9 and 4 year old watch it. Then again, she was 24, jobless and unfaithful.
Hence, the "ex"...
Seriously though, why they even felt compelled to rank shows like Dexter and Family Guy are beyond me. I understand they're the parent tv council, but unless they're allowing their children to watch these shows in the first place, their opinion on the matter is pretty irrelevant. It's the parents responsibility to determine what is and isn't appropriate for their own children, not Nissan and GMs.
Reply
AZZO45b 11:58AM (12/01/2008)
Are we talking about Dexter the Showtime cable show? There is no advertising on SHO so WTF would this lame PTC call out Dexter?
Epyx 12:15PM (12/01/2008)
Dexter is a Showtime show but it was on network TV (edited) during the writers strike. I don't know if it is currently on Network TV or just Showtime.
AZZO45b 12:40PM (12/01/2008)
Forgot about the strike... yes, Dexter is still on SHO. However, if Dexter aired on network... most of the shocking stuff would NOT make the cut.
Another thought... if parents are letting the TV (& mature themed shows like Dexter) be the babysitter...
... they should have used condoms!
Avinash machado 10:52AM (12/01/2008)
Well last time it was AFA and Ford, this time it is PTC and GM and Nissan.
Reply
CBR 11:01AM (12/01/2008)
lol @ GlaxoSmithKline Holdings
I guess nicotine patches and herpes drugs don't appeal to children after all...good job PTC! Altough Beano still does...
Reply
DC 11:03AM (12/01/2008)
These people need to get different day jobs and stop being a sore on society's backside. Its not up to them to dictate who is "good" and who is "bad".
(On a side note, that is Santa's job)
But I digress, this organization's goals are worthless and shouldn't influence anyone in terms of what product they buy because of what program they advertise for. Its not as if they are funding al-quaeda or hezbolla.
Reply
Gregg 11:35AM (12/01/2008)
Santa Claus, or the same thing, most people's conception of God (making a list, checking it twice, gonna find out who's naughty and nice...).