• Dec 17th 2007 at 10:19AM
  • 19
Click the diesel Bimmer for a high-res gallery

At the 2007 Detroit Auto Show, BMW was prominently displaying their diesel engine technology, particularly the latest 3.0L twin turbocharged in-line six cylinder. At the time, BMW spokesman Daniel Kammerer told us that BMW would be introducing that diesel engine to the U.S. market later in 2008. BMW still hasn't said which vehicles would get the diesel although it's expected that that the first installations will be in the X5 SUV and 5 series sedans and possibly the new X6 crossover.

Here at the AutoblogGreen Garage we just couldn't wait another whole year to try out a diesel BMW and when we found out that Bosch had one the pestering began. As a supplier of diesel engine fuel and emission control systems, Bosch has a vested interest in the success of diesel engines. To that end, they have brought over a fleet of European diesel vehicles, many of which are expected to be on sale in the US over the next couple of years. Earlier this year we sampled the Chrysler 300 and Smart ForTwo diesels. The Chrysler in particular was very impressive, but this BMW was in a whole different class. Find out how the BMW 535d fared in the ABG Garage after the jump.




BMW briefly sold one of their early diesels in the U.S. market in the form of the 524td in 1985-86. That same 2.4L six cylinder turbo-diesel was even offered as an option in the Lincoln Continental of the same period. Like most diesels of that time it wasn't particularly powerful but it was smoky and noisy to compensate. With the passage of two decades, things have changed pretty dramatically. More than half the cars BMW sells in Europe today are powered by a variety of four-, six- and eight-cylinder diesel engines. For our test Bosch turned over a 2007 BMW 535d SE for a week's worth of driving.

The current generation E60 5-series has been with us since 2004 and the styling went a long way toward redeeming Chris Bangle. It didn't have any of the awkwardness of the earlier 7-series or the excessive surface development of the Z4. The muscular proportions look particularly handsome in the dark Monaco Blue of the test car. Starting at the front bumper the bodywork surrounding the twin kidney grille sweeps back to the A-pillars with a pronounced chamfer preventing it from looking too bulbous. On either side of the grille the headlamp clusters sweep back into the front fenders blending into a character line that runs the length of the body.

On both sides of the grille and in the rear bumper are proximity sensors for the parking assist system. During low speed maneuvering such as in a parking lot, the screen in the dash displays a plan view of the car showing any objects close to either end of the car. Sitting at a stop sign or traffic light a pedestrian walking in front of the car will set off an alarm if the system is turned on. Below the front bumper is a radar sensor for the adaptive cruise control system. This monitors the distance to the car ahead when the cruise control is engaged. If the car slows down, or someone pulls into the gap, the BMW automatically applies the brakes to maintain a pre-set distance. It then holds the lower speed until traffic ahead speeds up or you pull out to pass.



That same display in the center of the dash also an integral part of BMW's I-Drive system. As new cars kept adding more features and functionality over the last decade, buttons were needed to control it all. In response BMW created a large control knob on the center console that acts as a combination mouse, joystick and all-purpose knob. When it debuted on the current generation 7-series, it was roundly panned as being far more complicated than even having a mass of buttons. More recently, other companies such as Honda and Audi have utilized similar controllers on a variety of models. Having recently tried both the Acura RL and Honda Accord, I can say that the control knob idea can actually be made to work very nicely. It's not the hardware that's wrong in I-Drive. It's BMW's software interface that's absolutely horrendous. They need to completely trash the I-Drive software and contract someone that knows a thing or two about human-machine interface design to create a new GUI.



Thankfully, as bad as the I-Drive software interface is, the rest of the 5-series interior is mostly wonderful. Given the performance capabilities of this car, the front seats are a godsend. If you can't find a comfortable and supportive setup in these seats it's probably because your spine has been tragically contorted by some crippling malady. It might take you a couple of minutes to go through all the adjustments, but it will be worth it. The thigh support is longitudinally adjustable helping to avoid my most common seat complaint, that of too short bottom cushions. The lumbar support is adjustable for both size and vertical position. The lateral supports are adjustable for width to keep you in position during hard cornering. Even the shoulder support is adjustable.

The 535d arrived just as Michigan was getting it's first snow of the season. Thankfully there was some relief from the cold in the form of heated seats both front and rear. Changing direction was facilitated by a wonderfully thick rimmed steering wheel which framed clear legible gauges. The 5-series features dual zone automatic climate control so that each passenger can select their own comfort level. Fortunately, Bosch swapped the high-performance summer tires for a set of Continental ContiWinterContact tires in a 245/35R19 size. If you've ever driven in winter conditions with proper snow tires, you'll never want to go back to all-season tires. Real winter tires can provide immense grip even when putting down the torque of a monster diesel like the one in this BMW.

While the diesel engines of twenty years ago were thrifty with fuel, they did earn the reputation which diesels hold among American consumers to this day: slow, noisy and smoky. While that reputation may have been deserved then, nothing could be further from the truth today. The engine in the 535d is a 3.0L in-line six cylinder in the classic BMW configuration. Fuel is delivered directly to the combustion chambers via a Bosch Piezo Common Rail injection system and air is pumped in by a pair of turbochargers. The result of all this high-pressure action is 286 hp and, more importantly, 428 lb-ft of torque at only 1750 rpm. As with all diesels this is not a high revving screamer with the red-line at a relatively modest 5,000 rpm. However the almost flat torque curve combines with a 6 speed automatic transmission to provide fabulous acceleration that never seems to let up. If feels more like an electric motor if you ignore the pleasant exhaust growl. BMW rates the acceleration from 0-62 mph at 6.4 seconds and that was backed up by my informal observations, even on less than dry pavement.

Judging from the previous paragraph you might think this review belongs on Autoblog rather than ABG. While it would certainly be well placed there, this sport sedan is here to demonstrate that the refinement of modern diesel engines hasn't sacrificed the fuel thriftiness that old Rudolf's engines are known for. This 3825 lb luxury sport sedan achieved this performance while still going 27 miles on each U.S.-sized gallon of ultra-low-sulfur diesel during it's time on our garage. That's comparable to the much smaller Nissan Versa I drove several months ago and significantly better than the 2008 Scion xB that only managed 23.4 mpg. In fact the only vehicles I've tested this year that did better were the Nissan Altima and Ford Escape hybrids which got 32 and 30 mpg respectively. A significant portion of the driving in the BMW was in the city as well which makes it even more impressive. On the EU highway cycle, the 535d is rated at 43.5 mpg (U.S.).



The engine in this particular car was compliant with current Euro IV standards, meaning it's not fifty-state legal in the U.S. It is equipped with a particulate filter and never emitted any visible smoke or odors. Operation was smooth and quiet enough not to offend anyone. However this Euro-spec car emits too many nitrogen oxides to pass Tier 2 Bin 5 requirements. When BMW does introduce diesel engines to the U.S. they will be equipped with a urea injection system like the one already used by Mercedes-Benz on the E320 BlueTec. BMW hasn't officially announced which vehicles will get diesels other than saying they would come some time in 2008. Expectations are that the 5-series and the X5 will be the first US market BMW diesels since the 524td. So far, BMW has said the new 1-series will only have six cylinder gas engines in the US market. After thoroughly enjoying a week with this 535d, hopefully the new fuel economy regulations will prompt BMW to change their mind and bring the 123d to the U.S. A 123d running on B100 would be some serious green driving fun.



I'm reporting this comment as:

Reported comments and users are reviewed by Autoblog staff 24 hours a day, seven days a week to determine whether they violate Community Guideline. Accounts are penalized for Community Guidelines violations and serious or repeated violations can lead to account termination.


    • 1 Second Ago
  • 19 Comments
      • 7 Years Ago
      Scott, I spent a week with the BMW, including plenty of time messing with iDrive. The premise is fine and like I said other car-makers have made the concept work much better. The problem is in the software interface. It's a poor design, with things buried to many layers deep and in odd places. Canceling guidance in the Nav system was too annoying. Honda and Audi both do it much better.
      • 7 Years Ago
      I think this review warrants a posting on the not-so-green Autoblog. Even the non tree hugging types will enjoy a full size luxury that runs to 60 in under 6.5 seconds and gets 27 mpg city.
      • 7 Years Ago
      How is a car that burns diesel fuel and gets 27mpg 'green' in any way? 'Clean' diesel is an oxymoron and 27mpg for a sedan is shameful.
      • 7 Years Ago
      At the german web page http://www.spritmonitor.de (also available in english) you can see the real fuel consumption of lots of cars in europe. For the BMW 535d the average is about US 25.7 mpg.
      By the way, a gallon diesel is about $3.51 here in germany.
      • 7 Years Ago
      Nick- Until better guidelines and standardized testing are implemented for bio-diesel, few manufacturers will approve more than B5, even fewer B20. While the fuel may not cause any harm to the engine or fuel system, it does produce slightly higher NOx levels, and this could make the vehicle non-compliant with emission regs, meaning the manufacturer cannot endorse using the fuel. These regs are coming, they're just not here yet.
      • 7 Years Ago
      Sam
      we are glad you liked the car and the great combination of performance and fuel economy. Don't forget that they also emit on average 25% less greenhouse gases, which should make mother nature smile. Keep in touch with Bosch, rumor has it that they will have a very hot 123d roaming around in the spring that will light up the tuner crowd and still get amazing fuel economy!
      Clean Diesel....its GOOD,CLEAN FUN!!!
      • 7 Years Ago
      US$3.51/gal for diesel in Germany?

      It's $3.94/gal today.. IN NEW JERSEY!!!

      Grrrrrr.....
      • 7 Years Ago
      Bring on the 8 speed auto!
      • 7 Years Ago
      Greg, it's because most writers don't spend enough time with it. When I bought a BMW with iDrive, I'll admit - there was a learning curve. Some things were quite intuitive, others were not. (And I'm pretty technically savvy.) But after getting it set up with my preferences, including the programmable steering wheel buttons, I started to like the system for most things. There are some things in the car that are not the same as in many other cars, such as the fact that to cancel your turn signal, you push the stalk in the same direction as you did to turn it on. It took me a while to learn to do that, but once I did, I found (and still find) it to be easier and smoother than the other way around. (Sort of like the process of learning to touch type - a pain to learn, but much faster, once you have.) If you're an auto writer, however, and just get the car for a few days (or even a few hours), you probably wouldn't have enough time in the car to learn these things. And, so you'll write about how difficult they are.
      • 7 Years Ago
      Dear Dave A, also known on this string as 13,

      The new Clean diesels will not only out perform their gasoline counter parts on fuel economy but they do emit 25% less green house gases and will meet the same emissions standards as gasoline! What are your "non shameful" suggestions? a hybrid still has a gasoline engine in it and a full electric needs electricity. You have to make the electricity some how and I promise you it will generate emissions! Bottomline is we need to start doing something. Clean Diesel and Hybrids are a very good start. Also There are clean diesel cars in the "prius" size range that get well over 50 MPGs!. Can you suggest a full size gasoline sedan today with a V8 that gets simliar fuel economy? because that is the proper comparision based on torque ratings and driving performance. If jsut 30% of our on road fleet in the US was clean diesel, we would save 1.4 million barrels of oil a day. No only are they green, the help with our energy independence!
      So I must respectfully disagree with the shameful comment.
      • 7 Years Ago
      Guenther, in the Pacific NW USA we have lots of B20/B100/B99 pumps (soy or canola) but almost no B5 pumps. We don't have to worry about nox smog because the constant rain cleans the air. I have an e34 I would like to trade in on a new BMW diesel. They would sell a lot of 1 series TDs here.
      • 6 Years Ago
      Hi i m interesting in buying a BMW 535 twin turbo deisel sport M pack all wheel drive if possible thank you many regards from Greece
    • Load More Comments