What you've all been waiting for: Nissan GT-R vs. Porsche 911 Turbo
Performance on par with a Porsche 911 Turbo was a well publicized benchmark for Nissan engineers when designing the new GT-R. Nissan even flaunted its achievement of a faster lap time for the Nürburgring circuit as proof positive. While the information coming out of the manufacturer's camp was impressive, it also came with a grain of salt. Nissan's own marketing fluff was biased, of course. What then would be the result of the same comparison without the obviously one-sided view? Being the curious automotive enthusiasts that they are, the Inside Line gang decided to pool their resources and get the new Nissan GT-R together with a Porsche 911 Turbo for a little playtime.
The playground consisted of German public roads -- the autobahn in particular. The game was chase; Porsche versus GT-R, with the GT-R as lead. The Nissan's confidence through corners helped it to frequently diminish the 911 Turbo's visage in its rearview mirrors. The Porsche created unsettling stomach-in-mouth moments on turns navigated gracefully by the GT-R. The smoothness of the GT-R was due to its more settled suspension and ATTESA all-wheel-drive system, thus allowing the driver to step on the throttle in an earlier phase of corner exit compared to the 911. In conclusion, it was determined that all the Nissan marketing hype had some merit after all.
While the Inside Line article greatly explores the everyday characteristics and feel of the GT-R versus the 911 Turbo, there's another IL piece that gets the two together on a racetrack. The resulting driver impression is much the same: the GT-R can go head to head with the best of the world.
Thanks everyone for the tip!
[Source: Inside Line]
_opt_thumbnail.jpg)
_thumbnail.jpg "2011 Audi A8: Live from Miami")
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 5)
Carlos 11:02AM (12/14/2007)
Woo First!
Also I've never really liked 911's though people say that Porsche is passionate about their cars, I really can't get over the feeling that they are more like high performance appliances. Though, just like Lexus, they are really good at what they do, they just seem soulless.
Reply
scottdraws 4:49PM (12/14/2007)
I never knew what soul really was in terms of cars until I had the good fortune of piloting a 911 around Laguna Seca a few times. The connection with the track... the feeling of the steering... the responsiveness... the way the interior fits you like a glove... and the wail of the flat 6 behind you... Trust me, 911s have plenty of soul!
It's all about the driving experience--that feeling of being one with the car--and it's not something many manufacturers can pull off. Then again, why should they? That's not what most consumers are buying anyway. :(
Carlos 8:23PM (12/14/2007)
I driven one too, and though it has great steering and handles well it just seems so vanilla.
John R 11:06AM (12/14/2007)
That article was a great read. GT-R FTW.
"Will the real KITT please stand up?"
http://carview-img7.bmcdn.jp/carlife/images/UserCarPhoto/652129/p2.jpg
Reply
Grain 1:12AM (12/15/2007)
Oooh. Thanks for that link. The GTR in black is friggin' sweet!
TBlueMax 11:06AM (12/14/2007)
Good for Nissan - it may have taken a while for the GT-R to return but it sounds like it was worth the wait. With this new GT-R on the market, the competition should (or will have to) improve as well. Good for all of us.
Reply
Seminole 11:13AM (12/14/2007)
My God, after reading the article I am thoroughly impressed. Nissan did a hellova job wit the GT-R.
Reply
tankd0g 11:18AM (12/14/2007)
If you're in German anyway, just go to the friggin 'ring and do the test for real.
Reply
Bill 11:21AM (12/14/2007)
Love the car, love the performance... but I also love the 911.
I've been thinking to myself lately. Lets say I had an extra ~80k lying around. Which would I buy, 911 Carrera (S?) or a GT-R?
And I always seem to choose the 911, and I think I figured out why. The Porsche would be a better car the 90-95% of the time you're "just driving". The interior is that much nicer.
If Nissan offered a "Grand Touring" version of the GT-R or something like that with a nicer interior, I don't think I could find any reason to take the Porsche. I don't understand why they don't even have it as like a $10k option... stick something like the G35 interior, but a little nicer in the GT-R and they would be set.
I hope they do this at some point in the future.
Reply
djSyndrome 11:31AM (12/14/2007)
The GT-R is being pitted against the 911 Turbo, which is well into six figures. It will eat the garden variety Carrera S for lunch and spit out the bones.
Bill 11:58AM (12/14/2007)
Right, I understand that. I'm saying though... For the money ($80k give or take) I would rather have the (relatively) slower base 911, or 911 S because it has a nicer interior.
If they GT-R had an interior on par with the 911 for $80-90k, it would be no contest, I'de have the GT-R hands down.
I guess I feel like Nissan is losing potential sales to the "base" 911 because it has a nicer interior, and if they simply offered an upgraded interior as an option, they would have all their bases covered.
500 12:47PM (12/14/2007)
Bill, what makes you think the interior in a 911 is "that much nicer?" I've driven many nice cars -- Porsche, Mercedes, Jaguar, Audi etc, and I've always been underwhelmed by Porsche interiors. I just recently sat in a Cayman and 911, and compared to my Mercedes, the interiors reminded me of a Dodge. And have you been in a GT-R yet?
Bill 1:56PM (12/14/2007)
I'm not saying that the 911 interior is the be all end all of luxury interiors (Too many buttons, knobs and switches IMO), but it is heads and shoulders above that of the GT-R.
The GT-R interior, in my opinion, is it's single greatest shortcoming. I guess for ~$80k I want something a little bit nicer. Before I get railed on by those saying this isn't meant to be a luxury car blah blah blah... I understand that, but it is meant to be an "Everyday Supercar". Hell, the interior on a Civic Si/ many other cars under $30k looks nicer than the GT-R's interior. It just doesn't look "special". It's boring, unlike the rest of the car.
dionysus 6:15PM (12/15/2007)
looks like porsche is losing over car performance, as people start to compare interior.
Avinash machado 11:20AM (12/14/2007)
What needs to be kept in mind is that the Porsche has far better brand equity than Nissan. No matter how good the GT-R is, those rich enough to afford one will prefer the Porsche for the badge alone.
Reply
djSyndrome 11:30AM (12/14/2007)
I'd venture that the $50,000 savings versus the 911 Turbo might be enough to sway some people.
IK 3:35PM (12/14/2007)
Good.
Less snobs buying the car I want.
Me Too 11:44AM (12/14/2007)
I still take Porsche over Nissan.
At Nissan, couldn't they add some design to the mechanics? It looks like a $0.50 hotwheels car.
Reply
nissanfreak87 12:24PM (12/14/2007)
the GT-R has never been a pretty car, it's a completely different design, more muscle than elegance, it's just a different design language
cowboy bob 11:28AM (12/14/2007)
Like so many of these "tests", why? Just how many of Autoblog readers really will get a benefit from which one of these realitivly small sales segment cars is faster? Yea, it's OK to know, but what about some tests of cars a major portion of the public might really be in a position to buy? This kind of thing where we see coverage of all these exotics doesn't really help the average joe, or Fred, or....I think most of us have a little problem poneying up the dubloons for this type of stuff. Oh yea, all you who "really need" this stuff jump on me now. After all, that's what we do here.
Reply