The Great Portugese Barn Find hoax debunked but still going strong
We receive a lot of tips here at Autoblog. Some implore us to check out camera shots of an Audi R8 spotted in Santa Monica, others relay breaking news in the industry, and still more are just personal rants about the state of all things four-wheeled. And then there are the tips we get about the Great Portuguese Barn Find.
Hundreds of tips about this amazing discovery have been pouring in for months. They all have in common the story of a New Yorker's retirement gift to himself – a house on a few acres in Portugal. The house he found had been vacant for 15 years, the owners having passed away leaving no heirs. The property was being sold to pay back taxes owed, and besides the house, there was also a large metal barn on the land with its doors welded shut. Nobody took the time to see what was inside, so the property was sold as is. When the new owner and his wife arrived, they got to work opening up the barn and found - the barn find of the millennium. Inside the structure sat around 200 dusty classic cars. What an unbelievable bit of luck for the new owner!
Follow the jump for the real story.
[Source: Old Cars Weekly]
And we do mean unbelievable. Of course the whole thing was a net hoax, but some people still want to believe it is true, and so the story continues to circulate. After all, there's a whole gallery of dusty classics sitting in a dark warehouse that's pretty compelling. How could it be a lie?
Old Cars Weekly just tracked down the story behind the story, and the real explanation is almost as good as the hoax. What we are actually seeing in those pictures is the collection of an automobile dealer who over the years has added many vehicles that caught his fancy. He just drove them to the barn and parked them there, presumably waiting until he decided what to do with the lot of them next. About a year ago he sent in a photographer to document the collection, and those pics are the ones circulating the internet, helping to create and sustain this myth. So now you know the truth behind the Great Portugal Barn Find, and you all can stop sending us tips to cover it. Okay?
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
lena 12:18AM (9/11/2008)
Ok so a car dealer collected 180 cars and put them in a barn, but why weld the doors shut?Why not take the pictures himself? why hire someone to take pictures, why wait so long to take the pictures and why take pictures of the doors welded shut?
And the story could still be true, this "new" information just explains how the cars got there in the first place and who put em there.
I mean this man, who was a car dealer in the 70's & 80's filled up this barn with 180 cars and welded the doors shut . . . . Why?
1)Why weld the doors shut? Why hide the 180 cars, what are you hiding? The cars still have tags/plates. Who do the cars REALLY belong to? Who's name are they in? Why not just put locks on the doors, put up a fence or take some type of security action?? Why go through such extreme to "melt" the doors closed if you will, to have to go through more extreme tactics to get back inside?? Is he going to seal the doors again??
2) if he had died, who would get his collection? If these pictures were not taken and spread across the internet , who would know they were there?
3)why wouldn't he clean off the cars or turn them on once in while, or hire someone to do it for him since he hired someone to take the photos of the cars in the first place?
Why document the cars? Document the cars for WHAT? personal records?
4) Why have a 180 cars in a barn? Why just sit on them and hide them instead driving them, selling them, or show casing them? What does one do with 180 cars?
5) Maybe there was a misunderstanding, maybe some guy did buy this barn and did find these cars inside, and maybe HE hired a man to take the pics of the cars and maybe there was a car dealer and the car dealer DID die leaving his collection behind.
This "NEW" info answered my question: "who would put all those cars in there like that?
But It still leaves "WHY?" I mean really, car dealer or not, why put those cars in a barn??? And WHY seal the doors??? why hide them? And why let em sit for years?? Without maintenance, and occasionally turning them on??
I find it hard to believe a car dealer put a random 180 cars in a barn myself. I could believe a man bought the property and the previous owner left behind 180 cars but I would think that the previous owner (or person responsible) was in a Mafia years ago or something and claimed those cars throughout the years for what ever reasons and tried to keep them hidden for reasons. It's more plausible.
Reply
scubafast 9:04PM (11/19/2008)
Not believable...what, just because you own a dealership doesn't mean you can't be a little crazy? Some of the richest people I know are short a few cards out of their deck.
Nellydesign 3:49PM (7/31/2007)
I STILL SAY ITZ TRU!! GIVE ME DEM CARZEZ!!
Reply
mblommel 4:19PM (7/31/2007)
ALL YOUR CARZ ARE BELONG TO US.
Rolf B 3:53PM (7/31/2007)
Maybe it's time to get out a dust rag, Turtle Wax and saddle soap, turn a few wrenches, set up a paint booth and get some of these on the road again. It's a shame they just sit there for nobody to enjoy.
Reply
Patrick Perron 4:11PM (7/31/2007)
It's better than the money from someone in Africa with a name like yours ...
Reply
Barney 4:29PM (7/31/2007)
It's still a good find and story.
Reply
dhhornback 4:41PM (7/31/2007)
That was my camera phone that captured the R8, thank you very much!
Barney 5:06PM (7/31/2007)
You have a great cell phone and I thank you and it for the picture.
Gus 4:55PM (7/31/2007)
Yup, this year, some of these cars were at lisbon's classic car show.
Seems the gentleman in question has starting selling (and in some cases giving them) to people willing to restore them.
Reply
RickDom 4:59PM (7/31/2007)
I wonder how long before that guys gets a call from Jay Leno.
Reply
Barney 5:07PM (7/31/2007)
That would be a real treat. Leno should do a weekly car show.
Reply
Joe 5:16PM (7/31/2007)
He does... well, kinda
http://www.jaylenosgarage.com/
Barney 5:40PM (7/31/2007)
Thanks Joe. I had always gone through PM for his garage stories. This has more up to date entries.
Reply
alex 5:47PM (7/31/2007)
that dude's key ring must be frickin' huge!
Reply
PapaWhiskey 6:57PM (7/31/2007)
This is a testament to how gullable the masses are. For some reason people seem to think that if someone they know sends them an email with an extraordinary story, it must be true, so they hit the forward button and send it to all their contacts.
DON'T BE A LEMMING! VERIFY BEFORE YOU FORWARD!
It's real simple to do, just go to www.snopes.com
Reply
speedyc 8:08PM (7/31/2007)
I've been hearing about this story nearly 5 years! I found that it was bogus about 3 years ago, and have posted replies every time trying to kill this stupid story.
However - at least once a month someone will post it, or email it to me.
They say nothing ever dies in cyberspace, and this proves it!
Reply
Phoebe 8:28PM (7/31/2007)
It made me happy to see a Magnette tucked away in there. My dad is in the process of restoring his own Magnette right now. I'll have to forward this story to him, he'll be amazed at the cars.
Reply
J 8:33AM (8/01/2007)
It made it to the top of digg so how can it not be true?
Reply
Frankie 6:06AM (8/02/2007)
Portuguese? The cars in the barn have dutch classic plates?!
Reply