Filed under: Etc.
Save Top Gear from its own success
Clarkson's at it again, casting shadows of doubt on the future of Top Gear. The celebrity automotive journalist (perhaps the most well-known, period) claims that while the BBC program ranks among the most watched television shows on the air, and that its audience continues to climb "like an F-15 on combat power," Top Gear is facing serious problems which could jeopardize its future.
The first, according to Jezza, is that following Richard Hammond's miraculous recovery and return to the show, the production schedule got horribly delayed. Clarkson figures that it takes about half a year to produce a season, which puts them severely behind schedule for the next series. Even if the show were to return in October, which he figures is the earliest a new series could air, Clarkson cites disgruntled fans who lamented the lack of content in the hastily-produced and recently-concluded 9th season.
"The series that's just finished was full of us three cocking about, and almost completely devoid of anything you might fairly call a 'road test,'" surmised Clarkson in his recent column. "This has gone down very badly with the people in internet land." (Hey, is he talking about us?)
Clarkson fears that most television viewers don't want to see him and the gang driving Ferraris and Lamborghinis, but just want to be entertained, and that if and when the show does return for a tenth season, it stands the danger of being watered-down. But it's the extraordinary track tests and tire-munching road trips that made the show as popular as it is. Top Gear, it seems, needs to be rescued from its own success.
Cheerio for the tip, Kim.
[Source: Top Gear]
_opt_thumbnail.jpg)
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
paul34 4:18PM (4/15/2007)
I agree completely, and I'm glad Clarkson noticed it as well.
Reply
Bob R. 4:20PM (4/15/2007)
I like how they test a whole bunch of cars. Sure they test Ferraris, Astons and Lambos, but they do offer tons of other great features on the show like seeing is an Aston is faster through France than a train, building Limos, Rocket Launches, Trip to America etc. I think Top Gear should stay the way it is for the 10th season.
Reply
Will 4:25PM (4/15/2007)
It's the "cocking about" of those three characters that grabbed the attention of people like myself. After having seen the 8th season, and the wild antics contained within, I bought the entire set of DVD's from the BBC. No easy feat when you're an American living in Japan.
Seriously, it's the craziness (like the Toybota and convertible minivan) that makes this show great. No doubt the Stig, and the more serious tests, is the foundation that the show is built on, but I, for one, enjoy the loons Clarckson, Hamster, and Captain Slow.
Reply
C 5:01PM (4/15/2007)
I enjoy the odd moment of British lunacy as much as the next guy, but the 9th season was made up almost entirely of contrived stunts. It's good to hear that was partially a result of limited time, and that Clarkson (that endearing buffoon) doesn't want to see the show lose all its relevance.
Reply
Matt 5:12PM (4/15/2007)
I think season 6 was the best, it found the correct balance between hijynx and road tests. I think J.C has to make a decision if the show is going to be about 'test drives and cars' or if its going to be just fun and entertaining mindlessness. personally i hope it goes back a few seasons and gives us the AMAZING reviews and cinematography such as the E39 M5 review.
dont get me wrong i like to 'what's faster' skits, but i just dont understand what the show in the last two seasons was 'about'....
Reply
J 5:15PM (4/15/2007)
I really hope Top Gear doesn't get rid of their road tests. They don't just test super cars which is great, but when they do no one can do it better. Segments like the Bugatti Veyron going flat out, the Z06, the Ford GT, Carrera GT and the trip in the Zonda, F430 and Ford GT to France were some of the best TV ever for me. The cars, the laughs, and the opinions are what Top Gear is about. That's what viewers want.
Reply
Matt Dell 5:15PM (4/15/2007)
He's got a point, for sure.
Reply
AW 7:02PM (4/15/2007)
Some people say that Clarkson is just a tosser. They point at his hair. And they laugh. Look at him, they say, with his rock 70's jeans. He's just a great streak of cack. Can you imagine him racking out to AC/DC or Bachman Turner Overdrive. How would like him rocking you all night long? Bloody hell, no thanks!
This is what some people say about Clarkson. I just think he's a turnip.
Reply
CR 9:01PM (4/15/2007)
I really just like the car based aspects. The seventh season was great but these last to have been diverting from the top gear business model.
Reply
Ken 9:51PM (4/15/2007)
There is no reason they could not reach a happy medium between general car-related entertainment and actual car testing/reviews.
They have been doing well for a long time, but I think they just need to cut back a bit on the non-car-related stuff.
Honestly, it doesn't seem like much of a problem - just a case of reevaluating what they want to do - and I trust the three of them have a good idea what should be done on the show.
Reply
justin 2:55AM (4/16/2007)
I didn't like the fact that most of the shows last season were revolved around things that weren't cars. They had tractors, road making equipment and even a bloody rocket! What I miss are the road races between the three where they each pick a car and test them against each others. That's what I liked.
Reply
Luciano 5:48AM (4/16/2007)
Great TV program!
http://www.lucianobove.blogspot.com
Reply
Daniel Dacey 6:31AM (4/16/2007)
Hopefully the show will remain centered around cars. It wouldnt be the same without some insult thrown out to "the Colonies" (Australia), when a Monaro or HSV of some sort is reviewed.
Their original review of the Monaro was a classic! I just haven't seen another car show which is so much about being non PC and just having fun with other peoples very expensive cars.
Reply
The non-Paul 8:35AM (4/16/2007)
Top who?
Reply
chris 8:46AM (4/16/2007)
No, they're not talking about you Autoblog.
Reply
Todd 11:13AM (4/16/2007)
"No, they're not talking about you Autoblog."
Exactly, Chris. Clarkston is takling about the fans over at finalgear.com. We rarely talk about Top Gear at Autoblog.
Reply
Claes 11:52AM (4/16/2007)
I'm a total know-it-all gearhead that loves Top Gears way of "testing" cars and thinks that the last season was the best ever.
Reply
Rocket Punch 12:59PM (4/16/2007)
IMO, TG shouldn't change a thing. Screw the serious testing and hard data. TG is probably the only show that consistently surprises me from episode to episode.
Reply
Don 4:35PM (4/16/2007)
Aw, poor Clarkson...whining about super high ratings and millions of dollars made.
What a pooft.
Reply