• May 1, 2006
Many of us have already taken in Motor Trend’s May issue cover story in which an impatient MT staff pits Chevy’s Camaro Concept, not due out until 2008 if at all, against the Ford Mustang in a digital duel. The comparison occurred in a virtual world created by a simulation program called CarSim. While data on the actually-in-existence Ford Mustang was easy to come by, editors from MT has to consult with GM to cull information on the 2009 Camaro to use in the simulation.

For those who find reading about the comparison a bit one-dimensional, both CarSim and MotorTrend have loaded up their websites with not only animations of the comparison, but also a mini-app called SurfAnim that allows one to zoom, fly around and see the tests performed in slow-motion.

[Source: CarSim and Motor Trend]


I'm reporting this comment as:

Reported comments and users are reviewed by Autoblog staff 24 hours a day, seven days a week to determine whether they violate Community Guideline. Accounts are penalized for Community Guidelines violations and serious or repeated violations can lead to account termination.


    • 1 Second Ago
  • 11 Comments
      • 8 Years Ago
      To our Mac users: sorry, but you'll need to find a friend with a PC as the animations are presently unavailable for your platform.

      Which explains the crappy 1985 graphics.
      • 8 Years Ago
      The colors of the cars are that of the "Live Green, Go Yellow" campaign by GM.

      Subliminal messaging?
      • 8 Years Ago
      The numbers in the magazine are really off, and not realistic. The trap speeds are definately higher than they are supposed to be. I don't think that they did a very good juob.
      • 8 Years Ago
      That was one of the worst article to come from motor trend, part of the reason to let my subscription lapse.

      They didn't not bother to factor Cd and swept area into any calculations. How amatuer.

      Seriously, Ford will have to replace the horribly underpowered 4.0 V6 in the mustang with the 3.5 V6.
      They honestly think GM would bring a base Camaro with a 5 speed manual? 6 speed manual or 6 speed automatic.
      I think they learned their lesson with the slow pontiac solstice and saturn sky.
      • 8 Years Ago
      Apparently you guys were sleeping through the mid-90's when the standard Z28 rocked ass all over the GT. It continued until 2002 of course. Make no mistake, the LSx motors will always one up the modular 4.6, 5.4 liter motors that ford has. The only exception was the SVT S/C Cobras (03'-04) that put out around 390 at the crank. However, by that time the F-body was already dead. Look for the new Camaro to come standard with a LS2 or LSx 6.0L (400+hp) Z28, and a SS version rated in the neighborhood of 450+hp. If we are lucky we will see a ZL1 tag boasting 500+ hp. I would love to see ford try to compare their engine technology. ALL HAIL THE LS1!
      • 6 Years Ago
      Yea the mustang is better (sarcasim)!!! Thats why the camaro has a BETTER rating the the Sad but true mustang.. its sad how bad it is compared to the camaro.. chevy is one of the best car companies alive..
      • 8 Years Ago
      I read this article and laughed...

      I used to love MT. But the last couple years, they have just sucked.

      This "debate" is totally bogus. By the time the Camaro comes out, if it even comes out, the Mustang would most likely whoop its ass...both in sales and performance.
      • 8 Years Ago
      I would like to see the finish product going head to head and if you back in history you'll notice that Mustangs always have to be modify to beat the Camaro off the show room floor they are no competition so we know what to expect.
      • 8 Years Ago
      This is kinda lame.. of course chevy would "win" its not even BUILT YET. So of course they'll give it just enough specs to try to beat the mustang. but the fact of the matter is they cannot beat the VALUE of the mustang. Price vs. Power ratio is the best on the road. gives you more room to spend a few extra dollars on it.
      • 8 Years Ago
      "1. Yes that's all well and good, but who won? hah.

      Oh wait, Ford did, they got to market first."

      If you recall they did the same in 1965 and even with a 2 year lead they lost over 30% of market share after the introduction of the Camaro in 1967. It will be no different here as long as Chevy keeps the price on the same level.

      If there is one thing that Chevy does good, it is making amazing performance vehicles.
      • 8 Years Ago
      Maybe GM should build these virtual cars, might cost them less in labor cost :D. Maybe that could turn a profit finally. This animation is about as inaccurate as they come. Your comparing a 05/06 Mustang to a 08/09 Camaro. GM will most likely dumb down this car and I am sure Ford will be adding a few ponies under the hood before 2008.