Filed under: Ask Autoblog, Maintenance, Green, Tech
Autoblog Maintenance 101: Transmission fluid and filter
Automatic transmissions are among the most complex mechanical devices ever assembled into a mass-market consumer product. As a result, automatic transmission fluid (ATF) has a tremendously difficult task. It has to lubricate the myriad of moving parts, providing sufficient protection to components that will rotate literally billions of times over the life of the transmission. It also has to provide enough friction to the various clutches within the transmission. ATF also provides the vast majority of the transmission's heat dissipation, and serves as a means of transmitting hydraulic signals and power.
Yes, the demand on ATF is significant, but yet it's often neglected when performing routine maintenance. Transmission service is certainly not as easy or straightforward as oil changes, but considering the frustration and inefficiency of a transmission that isn't operating properly and the jaw-dropping cost of a rebuilt unit, we'll happily roll up our sleeves and crawl underneath our '96 GMC K2500 to show how it's done.
For this project, we'll need the appropriate fluid for the transmission. This is extremely important - do not attempt to fill the transmission with anything but what the manufacturer recommends. The GM Hydromatic 4L80E requires Dextron III, and we bought eight quarts since that's the amount our service manual states is required when dropping the pan. We'll also need a filter and a new pan gasket. Tools vary from job to job, but a set of sockets, a variety of extension bars, and a universal joint (or "wobble drive") will usually do the trick. You also may need a gasket scraper to clean the sealing surface of the pan and transmission case, and some solvent. Last but certainly not least, a large catch pan is required.
The type of fluid and filter change that we're about to show will replace only a portion of the system's fluid, and therefore is best suited to vehicles that are not long overdue for this type of maintenance. Before tackling this project, pull the transmission dipstick and perform a visual and olfactory check of the fluid's condition. A burnt smell or color indicates fluid that's far past overdue (or more severe problems), and it's recommended that the vehicle be brought to a service station for a flush of the transmission and cooler. If you do elect for a professional flush-and-fill, make sure that the filter is also replaced during the process. We prefer to perform this service on a regular basis (roughly every 25,000 miles), and therefore we don't worry about extracting every last bit of used fluid.
If your transmission pan has a drain plug, consider yourself lucky while you remove it to start draining the fluid. In this case, we're not that fortunate, so we start by breaking loose each of the pan bolts with the appropriately-sized socket. Don't remove any of the bolts at this time.
Often, it will be difficult to access one or more of the bolts, so a bit of creativity may be required. Don't rush things, because tough bolts only get that much worse if the corners get rounded off. In this particular case, a 3/8"-drive socket was too large to fit over the bolt head (the transmission mount was extremely close), so a slightly slimmer 1/4"-drive socket was used. Shortly after this photo was snapped, the bolt broke loose and I slammed my hand into the crossmember.
Some transmissions will utilize the pan bolts to secure various brackets, especially for the shift cable. If that is the case, remove only those bolts, and move the offending components out of the way.
Yes, I'm aware that my camera's flash still sucks, in large part due to the Ziplock bag that protected the body of the camera during these photography sessions.
Once all of the bolts have been loosened, remove them, leaving one in place at each corner of the pan. Once this is
done, pick a corner to drop first (the front right corner looked to be the best bet in our situation). Remove that bolt,
and loosen the others as required to start draining the fluid. As you can see, the fluid will start leaking from almost
around the entire pan, so a drain pan at least the size of Montana the transmission will need to be in
place to catch all of it. Keep the kitty litter handy to soak up any spills.
Once the flow of fluid stops, remove the remaining bolts and carefully lower the transmission pan. A substantial amount of fluid will still remain, so keep the pan as level as possible.
Here's what the valve body looks like. We recommend against poking around too much, as it's a rather delicate assembly. In this case, the filter is removed simply by pulling it down with twisting motion, being careful not to snag any of the wiring harness. We'd also recommend not dropping it into the drain pan and splashing ATF onto the lens of your digital camera (not like we would know anything about that).
We'll now let the transmission drain for a while as we tend to other tasks.
The fluid that we recovered gets measured so that we know how much to add during the refilling process. We recovered five quarts, and added an estimated half-quart to this amount to compensate for what was spilled (and soaked up by my shirt) during the process.
Next, we clean out the pan. It's entirely normal to find a fair amount of sludge and other wear debris, but significant amounts of ferrous material (such as that which is stuck to the magnet in the bottom of this pan) may indicate problems. This transmission has always made a racket in 1st gear, which can be an indication of planetary wear in this particular model (it can also mean absolutely nothing). We'll continue to keep an eye on things during future fluid changes, but there's not much use in obsessing over it at this point.
At this time, you may choose to install a drain plug kit, or fit an aftermarket pan that includes one (some aftermarket pans also increase fluid capacity). We decided to forego that step, as leaks may result from modifying the pan.
Clean the sealing surface of the pan using some solvent (we used brake cleaner) and a Scotchbrite abrasive pad. If a cork gasket was previously used, it may be necessary to break out a gasket scraper, but be careful not to gouge the surface.
Place the new gasket in place. In this case, it turned out that the existing gasket was the reusable sort, and was of significantly higher quality than the cheap cork gasket that was supplied with our filter.
Also clean the transmission case, using extreme care not to damage the sealing surface or introduce dirt into the transmission internals.
Here's the replacement filter. Exciting, eh?
Take note of the filter's seal. It's obviously ideal to remove the old seal from the transmission if it didn't come out when removing the filter, but don't attempt this unless you're sure that you can remove it without damaging the transmission. While they usually pop out with ease, we've run into a couple of them that have been stuck in place and have added significant time to the project. If in doubt, leave the old seal in place, because once it's been damaged by a ham-fisted removal attempt, there is not other choice but to change it out.
Tap the new seal into place using a soft-faced mallet.
Gently press the new filter into place. Make sure that it is fully seated.
Gently lift the pan into place while attempting to keep the gasket lined up properly. This may take a few attempts. Install the pan bolts and snug them up, but don't tighten them yet. Feel free to make fun of the oily fingerprints that I've left on the outside surface of the pan.
Next, torque the bolts to the correct value (22 ft-lbs in this case, for those that are curious). If no tightening pattern is provided in your service documentation, simply go around the perimeter of the pan.
Before crawling out from under the vehicle, it's not a bad idea to clean off the exhaust if you've dripped fluid onto it during this process, or else you may get an unpleasant surprise shortly after starting it for the first time.
The correct amount of fluid is used to fill the transmission through the dipstick tube. We then start the engine, shift through each of the gears, and check the fluid level according to the manufacturer's recommendations (according to the dipstick, it should be done in Park and with the engine running). In this case, there are two ranges marked on the dipstick - one each for "hot" and "cold" - and so we don't need to warm up the transmission completely to perform a preliminary check. Once we verified that it was in the ballpark, we went for a drive to warm the trans to its normal operating temperature before we made a final observation of the level and checked underneath the vehicle for any leaks.
Since we're filling the trans through the dipstick tube, any pooling can hinder our efforts in obtaining an accurate fluid level measurement. Therefore, it's important to be patient while verifying that the transmission is indeed properly topped-off, as underfilling or overfilling may result in severe damage. Checking transmission fluid levels can be a significant challenge, which is why many manufacturers have removed the dipstick entirely in favor of measuring the fluid level electronically.
The old transmission fluild should be recycled, of course. Our local recycling center simply mixes it with waste oil, but you'll want to check with your location to see what should be done with it as to avoid contaminating a large amount of recycled material. At this time, we're unaware of any efforts to recycle automatic transmission filters, so we let the part drain for at least 24 hours and then dispose of it.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Bob Miller 11:44AM (3/31/2006)
I've been thinking about doing this in my 98 GMC Jimmy. It's a 2WD with what I believe was the only available engine, the 4.3L V6.
This vehicle has over 100k on it, and the fluid was cleaned the last time I had the vehicle in the shop (yes, the a/c compressor blew out at 95k, but other than that, the Jimmy has been fairly reliable). Anywho...my mechanic said the fluid looked great, and shouldn't be changed.
I'm still toying with the idea of ignoring his advice and having him do it anyway, just for the sake of good order (I don't want to do it myself). I've heard that if you wait too long, you can actually do more harm than good by trying to replace the fluid and filter.
Your thoughts?
Reply
amorak 11:57AM (3/31/2006)
Has anyone ever come across a pan for GM's 3T40 that has a drain plug built in? I'd like to buy one but can't find one ... :(
Reply
JPV 11:58AM (3/31/2006)
Good rule of thumb - If you can't recycle a harmful chemical you should seal it in a container and put it in the trash. NOT a drain or the ground.
If there is no tightening pattern you shouldn't go around the perimeter. You should start somewhere convenient and go 180 degrees (or every 90 degrees if you're good) from there for the next bolt. Then shift over one bolt and repeat until you're done or get lazy.
Reply
JIm 12:26PM (3/31/2006)
Bob Miller. Change your fluid. The "don't change it because" always comes up and it's bunk. My Ford dealer has what I call "secret sauce" (after the McD's) they put in and run for a short period prior to changing. It's just a strong solvent/cleaning agent, I really don't know. I change mine about every 30K because I tow and because Ford had some issues with its early Explorer transmissions. If I didn't tow I'd change at 50-60K. It's working fine at 160K, knock on wood. The service mgr suggested, and I agree, the first time the fluid is changed remove the transmission pan to check for foreign matter (metal filings etc), after that just push in new behind the old via the fluid cooler lines.
Amorak. I did that once on a vehicle but would never do it again. As noted above, the first change remove the pan, after that push out the old with the new. Yes, there is some mixing, but a good shop will take a few extra quarts to make sure the maximum is changed. Costs me about $75 every other year.
FYI, pull the stick and smell the fluid. If it smells burnt you'll know it, and it's time to change. If it smells burnt after only 10K miles or so, think about adding an additional transmission oil cooler. Heat is the big enemy and they can be installed for less than $200, less than $75 if you do it yourself.
Reply
Chris 12:37PM (3/31/2006)
I'm not arguing against transmission maintenance but how does BMW get away with sealing their transmissions on all 3 Series newer than 1999?
I understand the fluid doesn't even have to be changed. Please correct me if I'm wrong, but if I'm correct, please explain how they can do it?
Reply
MikeW 5:25PM (3/31/2006)
The torque curve on the M52tu engines is pretty flat, peak torque@3500 rpm and the GM 5L40 has smart BMW programming. So that the torque converter is locked up more often than not.
So the primary heat source of transmission fluid [torque converter] is eliminated.
The 5L40, made in france, is made to high tolerances and is 'broken in' at the factory so no 'grit' will come off gears and clutches.
Reply
Bobby 5:31PM (3/31/2006)
I think the BMW's and Mercedes (not sure if all models) use a newer long-life Hydraulic fluid instead of regular transmision fluid. I know that in my friend's E350 manual it says to replace the fluid after 100,000 miles. But everyone is saying be prepared to sit down when you see the price.
Reply
Phil L. 5:47PM (3/31/2006)
Thanks for the continuing "101" series.
Some items to note:
- A surprising number of vehicles now have reusable gaskets, which helps get rid of some of the excuses many DIYers use to avoid this job. I've done several changes and have had no problems with these gaskets.
- As you noted, a number of vehicles have filter seals that tend to stay in the transmission - and are very difficult to remove without risking damage to the mating surface. In all the cases I've seen this, it made sense to leave the old seal in place (provided it appears to be in good shape; in my experience, they usually are). Annoyingly, the seals are also difficult to remove from the new filter, but I've had no problems with this approach.
Eric: I hope a future "101" article will include brake fluid bleeding, another often-ignored maintenance item.
Reply
m 6:23PM (3/31/2006)
Good call with the brake line bleeding request Phil; I second that. Another great post Eric! by the way, what type of engineeering is your degree specifically in?
Reply
Eric Bryant 6:50PM (3/31/2006)
Bob,
It's my opinion that the people who have experienced transmission failure shortly after changing the fluid would have had a problem anyways. A lot of folks wait to change the fluid until they start having problems, and by then it's far too late. If the transmission is currently operating correctly and is due for a fluid change, I would recommended performing this service task.
Chris,
I can't speak for BMW's transmission maintenance schedule. I'll simply say that I'm uncomfortable in general with the modern trend towards reduced maintenance, especially considering that a wide variety of parameters (increased engine power, reduced packaging volume) intuitively has made the transmission fluid's life harder, not easier. I've seen the 100K change interval stated for many vehicles, and the only way I'd run that long on the original ATF would be if I intended to sell the vehicle at 101K :)
Phil,
We've definitely got you covered on the brake angle; check back soon (that particular project is going to get wrapped up tomorrow morning to make room in the garage for additional features). We go into it further than just bleeding.
m,
I have a degree in electrical engineering. That means I know just about enough to be dangerous with tools ;)
Reply
WTF NOOOOOOOOO 10:46PM (3/31/2006)
What?!?! NOOOOOO that only replaces like 5 out of the total of 7 or more quarts in your tranny. The torque converter is still full of old fluid if it is an auto. The lines and all that too. The best bet if it is an auto is to have the whole system flushed. Think about it, does an oil chnage mean replacing the filter and adding a quart?
Reply
Eric Bryant 10:17AM (4/01/2006)
WTF,
If the fluid is burnt or otherwise well past the end of its useful life, then indeed the remaining fluid poses a potential problem if left in the transmission. However, if the fluid is changed on a regular basis, there is absolutely no need to flush out all of the remaining fluid. I believe that this was clearly stated at end of the 4th paragraph.
Reply
Jim Hufferd 11:10PM (4/16/2006)
My 95 Mailbu is starting to leak around the tranny pan, I tightened it up which seemed to help. If I need to replace the filter and gasket HOW do I add the new fluid and how MUCH? There is no dipstick or opening to do so. The owners manual says take it to the dealer for service.
Reply
David Horvath 6:54PM (4/22/2006)
I've been putting off changing my automatic transmission fluid. As far as I know the fluid has never been changed with 170,000 miles on it. (1999 Chevy Prizm) I have been told by several people that if it hasn't been changed that at this point don't do it because I will have problems once I do. However, the transmission works great. AAMCO recommended that I have it flushed and that I will have no need to worry about problems developing. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Reply
Tim Kraemer 11:25PM (5/08/2006)
GM 3t40 transmission. I just ran into this blog. I hope it's ok to post questions. If not could somebody direct me? I've got a 92 olds wagon that blew a cooler line. After that it seems like it's in forward gear in all gears including Park and reverse. It only revved a few times when it was low. Could this be something as simple as an o-ring in the valve body? Or should I start searching wrecking yards?
Reply
David 9:51PM (5/28/2006)
Obviously it's not the best method, but I just removed my old ATF from the dipstick with a siphon taped to a wire shirt hanger (for maneuverability). How does this compare to a drop-pan job as far as how much of the fluid is removed? Will this method likely drain fluid from the torque converter?
Reply
Tiger 8:19PM (10/09/2006)
My mechanic says my 93 Eagle's tranny is dying. I was hearing a high whine, which he said was the tranny, and that changing the fluid would do no good. I also smell that "burning" that was mentioned several entries back, and just wonder if a fluid change could correct things (I can dream, can't I?) Any feedback will really be appreciated!!!
Reply
Ben Cook 10:58PM (10/31/2006)
I have a 1995 Pontiac Firebird 3.4L V6 with 183,000. I don't know how often the fluid was changed but my dad said not to mess with it after 100,000 miles. Should I take it to have the fluid changed or leave it. It runs fine and I get on it sometimes and perfoms perfectly.
Reply
John Stegman 11:47PM (11/26/2006)
Thanks for the tip about leaving a "stuck" filter seal in place. I spent hours removing the last one, but I had no idea when the transmission was last PROPERLY serviced (I don't trust Long Island, NY auto shops) so I went the extra mile (and two hours) to carefully remove the old seal. This time I'm at 25K miles past my last filter/fluid change so that little baby is staying in there this time. You guys made my day! This is a GMC 4T60 transaxle that's never had a problem after 167K miles so far, except for a bend in the pan lip thanks to "a butcher with a screwdriver and in a hurry" to service the transmission.
Reply
Dave Bazinet 7:54AM (12/04/2006)
I am driving a '67 International Travelall with an automatic tranny....it requires Type "A" fluid....what is the acceptable fluid I can use from those available today....Thanks! Dave
Reply