Biodiesel is the wrong answer

George Manbiot 250

So says George Monbiot in an editorial published in the Guardian December 6.

Perhaps best characterized as an environmental activist, Monbiot writes a weekly column for the Guardian and is currently visiting professor of planning at Oxford Brookes University.

In his article "Worse than Fossil Fuel," Monbiot maintains that biodiesel has an environmental impact worse than the fossil fuel it replaces - he calls it the world's most carbon-intensive fuel.

The problem is that producing enough biodiesel to fuel a significant fraction of the world's vehicles will require oil from palm trees - the most efficient oil producing crop in the world. Unfortunately, clearing tropical lands for oil palm plantations requires burning off vast areas of forest, and draining and drying of tropical peatlands, both of which release enormous quantities of carbon.

With the EU pushing for biodiesels as the feel-good answer to transportation fuel, and millions of hectares of tropical forest being cleared to meet the demand, Manbiot is harshly critical of the U.K. government - "It is prepared to sacrifice the South East Asian rainforests in order to be seen to do something, and to allow motorists to feel better about themselves."

His arguments are interesting and well-reasoned. Check it out. Also see his earlier article on the same subject here.

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)








Autoblog Podcast #158: 'Twas a couple nights before Christmas...

Chris, Editor Paukert, and Dan send the Podcast off for the Christmas holiday in proper fashion

 
 

Subscribe via: iTunes | RSS


Featured Galleries

  • Gran Turismo 5 Demo
  • Spy Shots: 2011 Lincoln MKX
  • Spy Shots: 2011 Ford Edge
  • MINI Beachcomber concept
  • Gold Mercedes-Benz SLS for Dubai Motor Show
  • 2011 Mercedes-Benz E-Class Cabriolet
  • 2011 Audi A1 Graffiti Teasers
  • Reader Spy: SRT-prepped Dodge Journey R/T
  • 2011 BMW Z4 sDrive35is
  • Ferrari P540 Superfast Aperta
  • 2010 Dodge Viper ACR-X
  • First Drive: 2010 Lexus GX460
AOL Autos

Find Your Next Car

Autoblog Video


Autoblog Green

BloggingStocks

Download Squad

Engadget

Joystiq

Autoblog Spanish

Switched.com

FanHouse

Asylum